Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

The comp ratio is swept vs unswept volume. Very simple. It gets much more difficult once the engine is spinng, as now the cam timing, condition of the valves and ring seals and head gasket play a part, along with volumetric efficiency, temperature etc. To figure out an unknown engines comp ratio from a comp test is never going to be accurate. Cam timing plays a huge role. If you are buying a built engine ask for the actual figures. If you are happy to assume its a high comp ratio motor based on that test, (which changed a fair bit once you asked for confirmation) by all means buy it.

^^ this! Some very very early combustion engines had low compression figures from the factory due to the low CR of around 6 to 1

Id say rob is running 8 to 1 CR as hi boost turbos ADD a lot of compression pressure to the engine therefore lowering the CR he can run (part governed by fuel octane)

Settle down. explain to me how an engine when built has a certain compression test result, then when worn had a lesser compression test result? Did it's comp ratio drop? can you run more boost cos it has less comp ratio? NO. explain how comp ratio effects the comp test results please :)

Ive compared 2 identical engines before, one with 150psi ( supposed to be 7.6-1) each cylinder and one with 180psi, and the one with 180psi cleary had more balls, the 180psi one had the head shaved which would of increased the comp ratio..

also a previous rb20det that was in nice condition, showed up as 150psi on average, showed 100rwkw without intercooler so about right I think, just for reference

Edited by AngryRB

^^ this! Some very very early combustion engines had low compression figures from the factory due to the low CR of around 6 to 1

Id say rob is running 8 to 1 CR as hi boost turbos ADD a lot of compression pressure to the engine therefore lowering the CR he can run (part governed by fuel octane)

Ive compared 2 identical engines before, one with 150psi ( supposed to be 7.6-1) each cylinder and one with 180psi, and the one with 180psi cleary had more balls, the 180psi one had the head shaved which would of increased the comp ratio..

also a previous rb20det that was in nice condition, showed up as 150psi on average, showed 100rwkw without intercooler so about right I think, just for reference

I have low compression pistons as they were lying around the shop at the time of my low budget build. Consequently I have to run 25 psi to make the same power as others do with 18psi and high compression pistons! It was a very slow build and over time I added more expensive components to the top of the engine (what you might call the wrong way round)! If and when my engine goes bang I will rebore and fit 9.5:1 forged pistons and properly balance everything.

must be a pain to drive off boost, im keen to do a rb30det with 9.5-10-1 with e85 and a 3076, nothing worse than a sluggish motor on the streets, but sometimes you just have to do the best with what you've got..

must be a pain to drive off boost, im keen to do a rb30det with 9.5-10-1 with e85 and a 3076, nothing worse than a sluggish motor on the streets, but sometimes you just have to do the best with what you've got..

Not at all a pain to drive off boost - accelerates quickly from 1000 rev/min in any gear. However your specs will make for a quick car!

Anyone thought about how the one doing the test could be straight up doing it wrong? Sounds stupid, I know, but hey, it happens. If he keeps cranking it until the gauge needle stops moving, it would read around the 200 - 210 mark. Some people just plain don't know how to properly do a compression test.

To OP, yes, 200+ is way, way too high. Look for a number around the 150-170 mark.

Source: Cranking my RB25DET comp gauge pressure up to 205 across the board to perform an (admittedly ghetto) homemade leakdown test just by bumping it until the needle stopped.

I take my reading when the need stops moving as per the book...

When I did my RB20DET I had two comp gauges to use, the lowest set of figures were 149 to 154 psi, the gauge that read higher also achieved a 5psi spread.

post-89296-0-01969300-1384556275_thumb.jpg

post-89296-0-65841800-1384556293_thumb.jpg

Anyone thought about how the one doing the test could be straight up doing it wrong? Sounds stupid, I know, but hey, it happens. If he keeps cranking it until the gauge needle stops moving, it would read around the 200 - 210 mark. Some people just plain don't know how to properly do a compression test.

To OP, yes, 200+ is way, way too high. Look for a number around the 150-170 mark.

Source: Cranking my RB25DET comp gauge pressure up to 205 across the board to perform an (admittedly ghetto) homemade leakdown test just by bumping it until the needle stopped.

Ive never seen the guage keep getting higher with longer cranking, in the first few cranks it hits the number and after that just bounces on that number, the engine just has what it has I don't get how you can make it higher than that.

I just got the reply 210. Cold. Does this mean the head has been shaved previously

There is not necessarily anything wrong with this motor. It may be purpose built as a high compression engine designed to run on race fuel or E85. Back in my youth as a Ford mechanic we used to get cars with high compressions caused by excessive deposits and they were routinely "decoked"... not a term I hear these days. If the engine is in a car you should test drive it with some form of det detection to see if it is detonating. Ask the seller why the compression is so high - did he build it himself or know who did?

Nah its from a half cut car import mob offering start up warranty only. I dont really care about how to do a comp test coz I do know how to do it. Im wondering what are the pros and cons of having a high compression motor

Google will give you a much faster answer.

Nah its from a half cut car import mob offering start up warranty only. I dont really care about how to do a comp test coz I do know how to do it. Im wondering what are the pros and cons of having a high compression motor

High compression is usually associated with a n/a. Low comp with forced induction. You trying to achieving any thing with 9.5ish.1 comp and above has a higher risk of detonation for your RB20det. Ideally for a force induction motor supercharged or turbo would be in the 8-8.5.1 range for reliable safe worry free function. This topic asking the pros and cons goes into a rabbit hole of controversy and opinion. Every engine builder believes what the do and how they build an engine equals to personal beliefs of religion aka everyone is wrong but themselves. I agree with Superben somewhat that no one will give you a correct answer unless you research for yourself. I hate telling someone to go "read" but in this case Google and the search function here on SAU is your best friend.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Because all parts that are put into your papers usually are assigned a badging if they did not come with one. So other people can just check that badging to tell if it is the parts your papes outline. But my pipe has NOTHING on it whatsoever. No idea why this even passed as a Mines pipe to begin with. I see this going two ways: -nobody cares and it's a non-issue, but that is unlikely -the pipe will just have to be assigned a bagding, for sake of argument, a Mines logo, and the papers corrected accordingly If it interests you I will post what the actual solution ended up being. All I care about is that it has to sound equal length and nobody can screw me later on because of a pipe being illegal.
    • The fasteners to the pipe are not subject to TÜV I guess, if we really start putting nuts and bolts through technical tests I'm going to hang the people responsible and then myself. Usually on a modern-ish EU normed car, you would just replace the pipe. Because if you start hacking away at it and welding new pieces on the cops will definitely find a reason to tow your car. That is just how it is sadly. On old cars and imports with no clear "standard" stuff like that won't matter too much. Most cops or inspectors probably won't even really know what they are looking at. But there is experts for this stuff even among cops, and some of them know the rules to a T and even have extensive knowledge about many vehicles. For "just a pipe" to be legal it usually is included in a set of parts, like a complete intake kit or a full exhaust. For example my exhaust needs to pass a noise test, meaning they have a standardized test track with a set of instructions and they run the car through there 3x for an average noise value that is 75dB(a) at point x of the test track. If it's above that, fail. For a turbo setup to be put in your papers you have to do dyno runs, emissions testing etc. So quite costly
    • Would this not be the same for the exhaust you've posted up?  If your exhaust volume and emissions are fine, why does the brand of pipe matter? 
    • The issue is more the fact that there is inspectors that deal with japanese cars a lot and they might know what a real Mines pipe looks like. And then they're gonna get antsy and not pass your car. But I'd have to talk to one of them about this, because you know as well as me that it's just a damn pipe and it effectively doesn't do anything. As I need to have my GT2860s and my exhaust setup (and the increase in HP) TÜV'd anyways maybe they can just correct the entry in the papers or assign a badge to the front pipe. I'm no expert either though, will inquire about this.     Thanks for the insight. Not sure if having a custom made pipe is good or not. Will find out in due time I suppose. Would be kind of funny if this was made in Germany though.
    • See this is a really tricky topic as technically the same rules apply to all cars but for cars but there is a difference. If you want to modify a car like the Skyline which never existed here you have a bit more freedom as they do not adhere to EU specs anyway. Any modification you do has to be in dividually checked anyway so as long as one of the inspectors think it's ok and within the TÜV ruleset you can get stuff like a top secret rear diffuser put in your papers. Which frankly would need a shitload of tests and certificates for EU spec cars, like a 2010 BMW M3 for example. But if you DO run these tests and all tests come out ok (safety stuff for the most part) there is no problem running such a part legally. It's just way too expensive to do for a single person on one car. The most touchy parts are emissions related mods, like an exhaust, turbos, air intakes. If it makes noise or alters the carbon emissions it's essentially illegal until you prove it's not. Meaning it doesn't exceed noise limits or have worse carbon emissions. I'd say for hoses if you replace them same same it doesn't matter what material they are or what brand you use. Same for nuts and bolts usually, they won't go and specifically check that your water hoses and some bolts are 100% OEM parts, that is nonsense.
×
×
  • Create New...