Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Some times when cruzing around my powerfc tells me that the engine is knocking its head off. oscourse if I acellerate then engine warning light comes on. I know this sounds bad but my tuner was in the car with me monitoring the know and said that it was getting really bad when we where going over bumps. He thinks that it is stuffed as the car should not knock when cruzing at 2500 rpm.

Also there is no noticable sound comming from the engine when this is occuring...

What do you guys think?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/43826-faulty-knock-sensor-or-detonation/
Share on other sites

on start it ranges anyway from 20 to 50 on the PFC. I dont think thats right...

Sounds like it's picking up other vibrations/noises.. because you cannot get knock on startup.

I believe most tuners can check the knock manually (and not via the PFC Hand Controller) by listening via mic's.. see if your guy can do it.

Have you checked the sensor is plugged in properly? Also, have you checked on the etc menu under sensor check - if a sensor is faulty it will be highlighted.

If I could hear anything coming from under my bonnet I would be very very afraid.

May be time for a second opinion. To just say its a faulty knock sensor, and not swap it out to make sure sounds a bit bodge to me.

Dont even risk it - I was getting knock on a tune of under 190rwkw. My tuner said 'nah, its not high enough to worry about' even though it was getting up around 80-90+ regularly. I got it retuned and it never went over 40.

meshmesh, why cant you get knock when you start the car?

I used to hide my FC hand controller because it made me paranoid! But on my 26 with forgies, (about 30% lower all round with cast pistons), the readings hovered around - cold start 40. Full load/big revs 55. Light load & cruise 10.

I do recall when I smashed no.6 piston it was a constant 120, with no audible sound from the engine.

On mine, the check engine light flashed whenever it exceeded 58. After doing a few engines, I would personally never exceed this level without thinking there was something wrong.

I did a test once, wanting to know how sensitive the sensors were. I tapped the sensors with a screw driver as best I could, and no reading at all registered on the controller. So I don't believe hitting bumps in the road will trigger a high reading.

My gut feeling is he's hurt your engine, and is trying to buy a bit of time by sending you away looking for a knock sensor fault.

Seen many a faulty knock sensor. I think it is presumptuous and alarmist to say the engine has karked it and the guy is trying to piss you off.

The knock sensor is a piezoelectric device which picks up vibrations at certain frequencies. It is also susceptible to picking up spurious vibrations when it gets a bit long in the tooth. No one engine is the same and hence even batch of knock sensors programmed to pick up knock for one rb25det might be a touch sensitive for another.

Only real way is to listen for pinging on the dyno or with chassis ears (placement is important) and have a safe ignition map in the first place.

Try –3 in the ignition trim and go for a rap down a safe stretch of road and record the max knock value. If it’s significantly different then knock is occuring.

The immediate above is coming from the guy that tuned my car beautifully and got rid of the sh1t tune that was on it from a major Sydney workshop who shall remain nameless.

Less timing, a touch more fuel and it has been going on the Power FC for 18 months like this.

Take some timing out and see if it fixes it. If it does, get your arse to a DECENT tuner now.

Adrian

  • 10 months later...

My Rb30DET has a little piston slap when cold and gets maybe knock 6 or 8 on the initial start.

Once idling with the slight slapping that can be heard the knock sits on 1.

knock level of around 100 I can hear the ping.

At 70-80 I get the tell tale sign of detonation on the dyno. Tell tale sign being the slight puff of smoke.

Once warm, I give it a bit of stick, I never get over 30.

Also as a word of warning. As SOON AS the petrol guage gets half way between the last 1/4 and Empty it leans out (I presume) and knocks up to 80-90 if I drop it back and WOT through 3rd.

First and Second I assume don't allow the fuel to swish to the rear of the tank and cause a slight lean condition as there's no traction due to my crap tyres. :)

Raw is usually higher (much higher) how it cals the monitored value I don't know. The SAFC2 has the same knock monitor and does the same thing. I just wanted to make sure you guys were referring to the displayed monitor value and not the etc, sensor check reading.

As for a bump not causing bizzarre knock readings, it can, if the harness plug is loose it will jiggle over bumps causing wild knock readings then settle back down. Pull the plugs off, clean the connectors and reseat the plugs before worrying about replacing the sensors themselves.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Very decent bit of kit. Definitely black it out I reckon.  
    • Because people who want that are buying euros. The people with the money to buy the aftermarket heads and blocks aren’t interested in efficiency or making -7 power, they’re making well over 1,000hp and pretty much only drive them at full throttle  best way to way make money is know your customer base and what they want and don’t spend money making things they don’t want. 
    • It's not, but it does feel like a bit of a missed opportunity regardless. For example, what if the cylinder head was redesigned to fit a GDI fuel system? It's worth like two full points of compression ratio when looking at modern GDI turbo vs PFI turbo. I'm pretty reliably surprised at how much less turbo it takes to make similar power out of a modern engine vs something like an RB26. Something with roughly the same dimensions as a -7 on an S55 is making absolutely silly power numbers compared to an RB26. I know there's a ton of power loss from things like high tension rings, high viscosity oil, clutch fan, AWD standby loss, etc but it's something like 700 whp in an F80 M3 vs 400 whp in an R33 GTR. The stock TF035HL4W turbos in an F80 M3 are really rather dinky little things and that's enough to get 400 whp at 18 psi. This just seems unwise no? I thought the general approach is if you aren't knock limited the MFB50 should be held constant through the RPM range. So more timing with RPM, but less timing with more cylinder filling. A VE-based table should accordingly inverse the VE curve of the engine.
    • I've seen tunes from big name workshops with cars making in excess of 700kW and one thing that stood out to me, is that noone is bothering with torque management. Everyone is throwing in as much timing as the motor can take for a pull. Sure that yields pretty numbers on a dyno, but it's not keeping these motors together for more than a few squirts down the straight without blowing coolant or head gaskets. If tuners, paid a bit more attention and took timing out in the mid range, managed boost a bit better, you'll probably see less motors grenading. Not to name names, or anything like that, but I've seen a tune, from a pretty wild GT-R from a big name tuner and I was but perplexed on the amount of timing jammed into it. You would have expected a quite a bit less timing at peak torque versus near the limiter, but there was literally 3 degrees of difference. Sure you want to make as much as possible throughout the RPM range, but why? At the expense of blowing motors? Anyhow I think we've gone off topic enough once again lol.
    • Because that’s not what any of them are building these heads or blocks for. It’s to hold over over 1000hp at the wheels without breaking and none of that stuff is required to make power 
×
×
  • Create New...