Jump to content
SAU Community

17" Vs 18" Wheels For Motorsport

BOZ22N

By BOZ22N,
in Motorsport Discussion & Builds

 Share

Recommended Posts

BOZ22N Grand Master

BOZ22N

Posted
Posted

Hi all,

I am selecting some new wheels for my R33. I am looking to change my car back to a more factory spec to be eligible for more Tarmac rally events.

One of the things I am going to change is the wheel size. If I stick to the 2" high and 2" wide increase rule I can go to 18 x 8.5 but the question is do I need to?

I am current ally running stock R33 brembos and am happy to keep using them so I can get away with a 17" rim.

17" PROS

I have weighed both options with a AO50 245 tyre and the 17" is lighter by 1.4kg per corner.

The 17" tyre is $70.00 cheaper per corner

18" PROS

Rolling diameter is 26mm bigger which would help me stay with the current diff ratio.

Might be able to pick up cheap second hand tyres for track days etc.

better brake cooling.

Saying all the above you all might have some more info for me to help

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/448403-17-vs-18-wheels-for-motorsport/
Share on other sites
BOZ22N Grand Master

BOZ22N

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Lol massive fail.

I dropped my phone and it sent the post before I was finished.

Fat hands and iPhone do not work.

Anyway as I was saying if you have any advice for me that would be great .

Things I don't know are reliability, handling and geometry changes.

Thanks for reading both my posts lol.

Dale FZ1 Veteran

Dale FZ1

Posted
Posted

Geometry changes? That's going to be dealt with in your suspension setup, not related to wheel diameter.

Price and availability of the sizes you want are probably the biggest deciding factors - if you can't readily get them, or they are ridiculously priced then you'd be looking elsewhere. Competing to win, vs entering to have a run are also far different things that means you might just have to deal with the price difference.

Assuming you're looking only at the Yoko A050, 245 section width. Are there different nominal aspect ratios, or tyre heights for a given rim diameter?

Big call to make any definitive statement about durability/reliability of the tyre based on its rim diameter, although a taller tyre is going to have more rubber to play with for a given distance travelled. I'd think the manufacturer would vary carcass construction and rubber compound for the different sizes and rated load capacity. There might be some merit in targeting specific tyre sizes because the sidewall height (or aspect ratio) is going to impact general stiffness/compliance levels and tyre response. Formula 1 vs other open wheel categories highlights this, in my mind at least.

Definitely a mind bender, there's probably going to be a bit of trial and error in finding what you prefer.

BOZ22N Grand Master

BOZ22N

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Thanks Dale all good points.

I was more thinking car geometry ie cog and rc than suspension. I don't know if this is correct but if I was to use the 18 the car would sit about 13 mm higher with the same suspension settings. Obviously this can be changed but just trying to limit the variables and just evaluate the tyre and rim combo on their own merits.

Thanks again and you are rite it might come do to it is just more cost effective to run 17's.

sav man Grand Master

sav man

Posted
Posted

18" tyres wear better than 17" tyres on a rally. The only geometry changes will be what ride height your car sits at, You need to make sure the suspension can use full compression without fouling on anything.

There is a few R33 GT-R's running round with 18"'s on, so doubt there will be any problems, it's just going to come down to $$

Neil Grand Master

Neil

Posted
Posted

Lol massive fail.

I dropped my phone and it sent the post before I was finished.

Fat hands and iPhone do not work.

Thanks for reading both my posts lol.

My advice would be to buy a real phone,,,not that shitty iphone crappy thing and these problems wouldn't happen.

Cheers

Neil.

  • 4 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • MBS206
      R32gtr sputtering and stalling

      By MBS206 · Posted

      Diagnosing with and without is mostly the same. You need to know, as Duncan asked, and what conditions. Car hot, cold, idling, driving, if while driving what rpms, is when you're varying, or is it when held constant.   From there it's understanding what can be causing it. Starting with pretending all of the sensors are correct. Which means if it's going rich, why would it be thinking more air is going in than it is, and under what conditions. So things like if only when under boost, it could be be a loose intake piping joint. It's just understanding the system, and understanding when/how the problem occurs, and then if it's only occuring in specific scenarios, what can be causing it.   ECU specifically, if it's aftermarket, it'll have software you can use, for the Skylines on factory ECU, there is Nissan Consult you can use. Most ECUs have a way to get data from them.
    • silviaz
      R32gtr sputtering and stalling

      By silviaz · Posted

      How do you go about diagnosing ecu's that don't have data logging, is it more experience at that point and just trying out things that you think will fix the issue?
    • MBS206
      R32gtr sputtering and stalling

      By MBS206 · Posted

      Stock O2 are basically useless beyond anything at stoich. Any misfire will also be seen as lean. The stock O2 also read a collective exhaust gas volume, not each cylinder. Sputtering and missing means not each cycle is firing, and some are. Which means even if rich, as shit, on cylinders as they miss, they'll read lean, but the cylinders that did fire will read rich, and combined, well, they can read anything from rich to lean.   Start with the basics before even going looking at sensor values.   Edit: I say the above, and that's coming from the guy with a few thousand dollars worth of scan tools sitting right beside me right now that I use frequently for my job.
    • sk8boy204
      Auto GTS4/Stagea transfer case.

      By sk8boy204 · Posted

      I just finished up a manual swap and I have a 1999 S2 AWD automatic in my garage, depending on where you are located. I'm in the the midwest of the US.
    • r32-25t
      R33 GTR N1 REO on an r32 ?

      By r32-25t · Posted

      I’ve heard it can be done, you need to redrill the holes where they bolt to the chassis and apart from that they are the same. I’ve never done it or know anyone personally that has, it’s just something I’ve heard 
×
×
  • Create New...