Jump to content
SAU Community

Vq35 Replacement

nzM35

By nzM35,
in Four Door Family & Wagoneers

 Share

Recommended Posts

nzM35 Rookie

nzM35

Posted
Posted

Hi everyone,

Just registered but have been reading here since I got my stag 2.5yrs ago.

Long story short over the last year I believe te bank 1 VVT cam sprocket has been on its way out. Replaced VVT solenoid with no success. Intermittent rough idle and lack of power. Throwing code p0011? Through the obd port and an app I can see the timing 'sticking'. After a lot of research, I'm 99% sure the cam sprocket is toast. No way to tell without opening it up. Nissan blaming the cam sensors.

Anyway, the repair bill for this will be huge. Apparently 20+ hours, even through amayama the sprocket alone is close to 1k. This job is not something I would tackle myself. I'm starting to consider replacing the engine completely, myself.

Question is, can I use a vq35de from a 350z or v35 skyline? I assume so but don't want to find out I can't the hard way.

Also considering the vq25det, depending on what's involved.

Cheers

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/461660-vq35-replacement/
Share on other sites
PN-Mad Grand Master

PN-Mad

Posted
Posted

Yes, same motor.

But a couple of points, the 350z had a rev up motor and later a vq35hr in it, so you need the motor out of the first models. V35s only got the basic model of motor.

If you car is AWD, you'll need to swap over the bits relevant.

Not a simple job, but do able.

I'd be very tempted to buy a whole set of crank angle, and the two cam angle sensors first however.

nzM35 Rookie

nzM35

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

ok sweet. I was aware of the hr and rev-up models, just making sure a regular vq35de would work.

Mine is actually a PM35, so RWD. Would this make it as simple as dropping the old and in with the new?

I have a couple of theories to doubt it being the sensors,

I never had a CEL come on. Only pending codes when I checked with a scanner. I bought 1 of those cheap bluetooth OBDII adapters and used that with an android app called Car Gauge Pro. Through this i can watch the duty cycle of the VTC solenoids as well as the timing advance from the cam sensors. When everything is working normally you can see the timing advance/retard in relation to the cam sensor readings. When it craps out (obvious lack of torque through the mid range) you can see the duty cycle of the affected bank either drop right out (if the timing is stuck advanced, ie its trying to pull it back) or if its not advancing as it should, the duty cycle increase alot higher, higher than it ever does when its running fine. If I keep driving for a while and it sticks the whole time the ECU shots off the VTC function all together, until I restart.

I hope that makes sense, but from what I gather, electrically everything seems to run just fine. Mechanically the only 2 things that can cause this are the VTC solenoid and the sprocket itself.

For the past 3 months while I've been working out what to do I've unplugged the VTC solenoids. The car just runs with no VVT now and CEL on, can you say GUTLESS! lol.

Oh and thanks for the fast response! I hope i'm wrong though...

Edited by nzM35
PN-Mad Grand Master

PN-Mad

Posted
Posted

Yeah, easier as a rwd.

Good luck with it all. If you haven't at least tried crank/cam sensors, it's a whole heap easier and cheaper than a motor change! You can always keep em as spares if they don't fix it and you replace the motor.

nzM35 Rookie

nzM35

Posted
  • Author
Posted

oh I forgot to mention the other reason I believe its the sprocket,

A few months before all this started happening I had an oil change done. About a month after that, when starting the car in the morning the idle would fluctuate for a few seconds and then return to normal. It did this fora 3 weeks until I checked the oil level on level ground at the servo. Found it was low (at the low mark exactly) and topped it up. That problem then disappeared. From my research, low oil can cause the sprockets to crap out. :facepalm: shudda checked the oil sooner!

nzM35 Rookie

nzM35

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Where are you ? I can recommend a couple of shops (not Nissan) that could have a look at it for you . If you do decide on a new engine there are quite a few PM35s wrecking.

I'm in Chch. The more I think about it the more it makes sense to repair it. Sure could do with a trustworthy mechanic

nzM35 Rookie

nzM35

Posted
  • Author
Posted

All you need is a good second hand cam advance mechanism, it isn't that hard to change. They are usually very reliable.

Yea, I've been thinking about it lately and think it makes more sense to repair.

Are you referring to the sprocket or the solenoid? I've already done the solenoid, new oem.

How hard is it to change the sprocket? As far as I know, once I get the timing cover off its basically a timing chain change doing the sprocket while there. That's where my balls drop. Never messed with cam belts or chains.

scotty nm35 Grand Master

scotty nm35

Posted
Posted

Pretty easy to change the sprocket seeing you have access to an english manual.

No need to change what isn't broken. Chains can last a lifetime if they are suitably lubricated, in other words if the oil has been changed regularly. I would be replacing the tensioner guide at least though.

KiwiRS4T Grand Master

KiwiRS4T

Posted
Posted

OK cheers Scotty. You answered my next question on replacing the chain and tensioner. Looks like I'll be giving it a crack in the new year. Thanks for the help!

Sorry meant to get back to you earlier. Dan in the parts department at Cockram Nissan is a Skylines Down Under member and has been good at getting hard to get parts for me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • soviet_merlin
      Baron's R34 GT-R build thread - car in Japan for 5 years -_-

      By soviet_merlin · Posted

      Just checked in first post and you should be able to bring it home November this year, right? I'm amazed you made it through four years of this. As hard as it feels now the rest will go by in a breeze in hindsight, I'm sure.
    • BaronOBeefdip
      Baron's R34 GT-R build thread - car in Japan for 5 years -_-

      By BaronOBeefdip · Posted

      Realized I haven't been back here in a while. Still here, still alive, still waiting for the car.  I went back again the only time last year from Oct-Nov for R's Meeting and drove it around some more, including a few laps on Fuji Speedway(in the wet, sadly). The car still feels good, but have a couple small things to address. I've been getting more parts but have slowed down still, and most of the bigger purchases are now out of the way. I find myself getting impatient more and more when it comes to getting started on this project; it's quite hard for me not being able to really dive in and start making this car my own because it's halfway across the world. At times it doesn't even really feel like I own one of these. Haven't really been motivated or had the desire to document the last trip on here or social media for, well, reasons... but here's some pics...it's also still alive and well as you can see: I've narrowed down to the last large part purchases(anything over $2k) before the engine build to be: 1) Ohlins Road & Tracks 2) ATS Twin Carbon clutch 3) Endless BBK with some custom options and 4) Kansai Service carbon driveshaft I don't think the budget exists for all of these this year, but I'll try for one or two items I think. Though, every time I look at my spreadsheet I sigh, shake my head, and get depressed just that little bit more.  'til later.
    • Shoota_77
      R32 GTS-t RB30 sedan

      By Shoota_77 · Posted

      It's a stunning location!  I've been to NZ twice but haven't made it to the North Island yet.  Definitely on the cards but the South Island is hard to tear yourself away from too... Looking forward to see what you can wring out of it once you can get it to hold together!  Be awesome to get a low 11 or even sneaking into the high 10's pass out of it.  That's a bloody quick car that most people will never experience in their life.  Enjoy!
    • joshuaho96
      HKS stroker kit step 0/1 or HKS GTIII 2530

      By joshuaho96 · Posted

      Nominally yes but I’m not really at that stage yet. Outsourcing to Japan is also a relatively good deal at the moment because their currency has devalued much more against the USD.  You would assume this but a lot has changed from the pandemic. Mechanics are in short supply and demand for fixing old cars has gone up from the cost of new cars. 250-300 USD/hr is not an unusual shop labor rate in California and you’re paying that regardless of whether the guy is competent or not. Coworkers have been quoted 3000 USD for a water pump and thermostat at a dealer on an N54. Oil changes went from ~75 USD to 150 on fairly normal cars like Civics. The cost of the oil and filter hasn’t even kept up with inflation.
    • GTSBoy
      HKS stroker kit step 0/1 or HKS GTIII 2530

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      The downside to that is that the cost of everything, particularly labour, is significantly higher here than it is over there in the Disunited States of Slavery. You can hire 3 tradesmen over there for just the Ranger Raptor allowance of a single 3rd year apprentice over here.
×
×
  • Create New...