Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

CA18DET Rebuild or engine swap?

Hi All, 

Recently my current CA18DET just blew up (cracked piston rings) and overheated.

Ive got a spare engine lying around with unconfirmed kms (obtained from a previous purchase).

My question is what would be the best path for just getting the car going again (and reliably).

Should I refurbish the engine back to OEM? or just bolt her up with a new head gasket?

Also, if anyone knows who is decent with CA's in Brissy, let me know.

 

Cheers

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/470485-ca18det-rebuild-or-engine-swap/
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

As one of the rare people still using a CA, you should give it all to me. 

  • What is this car? daily? track? drift? 
  • What do you want to do with this car? 
  • What power do you want from this car? 
  • What's your budget? 

If you have a spare bottom end, you could easily get it inspected by an an engine builder to assess condition. Then make a call about whether you can just slap a head gasket on it, all your old shit and go for gold. 

If it's a track car/you have a decent budget, then you have lots more options (and should do certain things). 

In stock tune, they do not "just blow up" and crack rings. Mine has done 146ks on a stock bottom end and is still being abused on the track with a mild 200rwkw setup. They are strong motors for the age/design. I did replace a head gasket, but that was due to my dodgy tuning learning adventure. 

Find the root cause, if it was heat related then you might have a fuel delivery issue leaning it out or an overboost issue leaning it out. 

Stock ECU? Stock turbo? Lots of questions. 

  • Like 1

:D CAs are pretty cool little nugget. I rebuilt mine in 09, it made 314rwkws on Pump 98 fuel using an old ATR43G4 turbo internally gated.

atr28g4316rwkw.jpg

 

And I sponsored a drive whom also had a built CA18det that made 344rwkws on P100 fuel using the same turbo externally gated.

 

atr28g4344rwkw.jpg 

Lovely numbers I must say

I've decided to go a fully forged bottom end. Keeping the s15 turbo for now. Targets should be around 300hp at break in and after 400+

We figured out after a bit of looking that it was a boost spike that blew the piston rings. 

I think you'll struggle to make 300rwhp on a GT2560 without some reasonable cams and even then I'm not sure.

You could try running it at 20psi+ to get there, but don't expect turbo to live long.

I run the same turbo and they are pretty much out of puff by 16-18psi max. Check the comp maps.

  • Like 1

Yeah I'd agree, at the end of the day its just a number. My main goal is a well balanced and responsive engine. 

Long term a set of good cams, injectors and a decent turbo should do the trick, maybe even an ATR43G4, who knows. 

Plenty of guys (well less and less in fact) here in France runs the CA18 with a gt2560r and the max reliable boost is about 18psi, anything beyond that and the turbo is just breathing hot air up top. Bloody good turbo for smallish/slowish track but it runs out of puff quickly. I agree that you'll not see 300whp with this turbo unless in kill mode, 280whp is more what it can make.

Cheap way for the cam is installing an exhaust cam at the intake to get a bit more lift or a CA16DE intake cam to get a bit more lift and duration. But to be honest don't bother, there is more to be gained with other breathing mode and a smart turbo choice than slapping cams on it.

A mate is using a GT3071 (not sure is it's the cropped 56.5 turbine or the 60mm one) internally gated on his stockish CA. The only upgraded internal parts are metal headgasket and ARP rod bolts. He was running 24 psi (E85) for years (mainly on track) and the oil pump let go last year.

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Incidentally, I also put v3 of the tune on the car and did an oil change from 5w20 to 5w40 to see how it affected oil pressure in the mid to high end. I'm still happier with the thicker oil and will stick with it, but clearly the system is happy with 55psi even if I'm not!
    • So the other thing I got sorted over the weekend was Z1 oil catch can install. https://www.z1motorsports.com/z1-products/z1-motorsports/z1-q50-q60-30t-baffled-oil-catch-can-kit-p-23546.html It was a good kit, most importantly it came with preformed silicone hoses in the right shapes rather than trying to bend/join regular straight rubber hose. It did come with crappy spring clamps not proper hose clamps so I ditched them On the down side, it is made for LHD cars and RHD cars have the main ECU harness running straight through that location, I ended up bending 2 mounting brackets so the loom is up against the brake master cylinder compartment wall to make room for it....otherwise everything fit without modification Intercoolers off on both sides, but there was enough room to get everything done without disconnecting (and therefore having to re-bleed) the coolant lines. Each is mounted with 4x 12mm headed bolts, plus in and out side hose clamps (7mm headed, nice) and 3 electrical connectors on the navigator's side which were a real pain to undo (probably for the first time in 13 years).   Also one of the mounting bolts on the driver's side was cross threaded, thanks Infiniti/Nissan workshop mechanics. On the navigator's side, the catch can plumbs into the factory hose that goes from the cam cover PCV back to the intake.  This is the 2 new hoses in place. All simples and direct fit On driver's side, there is a bracket provided that mounts to the throttle body, they even provide slightly longer bolts to allow for the bracket thickness which is nice (although, they don't have captive washers like the factory bolts of course) In that pic the main loom brackets are not in place, once I had "adjusted" them across it now sits up against the panel and just clears the OCC The remaining problem with this is emptying it; currently you have to remove the 3x m4 bolts that hold it to the bracket and both banjos to remove it (probably dropping the banjo washers at the same time) pull it apart to empty then replace. I do have some fittings coming for a remote drain from underneath that will also add a little capacity...it is very small and will need to be emptied every oil change to be sure.
    • Noise sounds to me could be either wheel bearing related (have had similar from bearings going) or that tail shaft is still loose. Or something like a heat shield touching the tail shaft.
    • You wouldn't get away with saying the opposite, if you were there.
    • Do some wool fluff testing on the vents
×
×
  • Create New...