Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Thought I would share my story as it’s the second time I have had this fault and a quick google shows it to often be misdiagnosed or the suggested repair is massively overpriced.

 

This one seems to be a very misunderstood problem as this happened while on the way back from a dealership service and they had completely missed the problem with the car. I was driving while in congested freeway traffic and noticed the engine temperature was climbing well into the redline. I had to nurse the car through some careful manoeuvres to force cool air into the engine bay. Luckily traffic cleared up and once up to normal freeway speeds the temp dropped down again but it was clear the temperature was related to vehicle speed and stopping at traffic lights had it shooting up again quickly.

 

This is the second time I have had this fault so diagnosis and repair was relatively quick and painless but I know from the first time I has this issue that the normal service technicians often completely miss the root cause and will recommend expensive repairs that only fix the problem by chance rather than knowing what they are doing, the fixes are often also expensive and require parts that are in fact perfectly serviceable on the car.

 

The fault lies in the engines electric cooling fans, the brushes in the fans have become stuck due to dirt fouling the action and they are no longer making effective contact with the commutator. With 4 brushes inside the motor there is some level of redundancy but after a while the motors become less and less effective until they are not functioning at the required speed. The fans will still turn but they will not reach full speed and will not draw the required air across the radiator, most service techs will just see a spinning blade and assume the fan is working.

 

The simple fix for this problem is to remove the fan housing from the motor, a simple job with plenty of how-to’s on YouTube, and then disassemble the electric motor housings. While not intended to be user serviceable, the housing can be opened with a screwdriver and/or some pliers. Between the 2 motors you will most likely find several of the brushes have become stuck with the spring pressure no longer enough to overcome the dirt and fouling accumulated in the motor. All you need to do is give everything a quick clean and maybe a little lubrication if you have the correct products. The hardest part is the reassembly, I recommend using sowing needles and thread to retain the brushes when you close-up the motor housing. Crimp the housing back together and reassemble and reinstall the fans.

 

All up the fix takes about 2 hours using only a screwdriver, pliers, a shifter, a drain dray and a rag. No new parts required, and the repair should last you another 2 to 3 years before having to repeat the process. This of course presumes the brushes are in serviceable condition, not cracked to worn but even then, the replacement brushes are cheap and simple enough to replace with a soldering iron.

Edited by Ghostfox

Good first post. Usually fan and cracked radiator are the first things I'd suggest to look at. The older RBs have clutch fans so are quite easy to check, but of course electronic fans are harder.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Update: I got the magnet out. I bought 3 different flexible magnetic reach tools, but none of them worked. The magnet on the tip was all less than 2lbs of force, so i had to buy a special cylindrical magnet that had a pull force of 9lbs.  The magnet finally came in the mail yesterday, so i got under the car to get to work. The super strong magnet isn't that long, so i only have about 1 finger pinch lengths to hold it. I was so scared when i was going in the hole, that the 9lb magnet would just fly away inside the oil pan never to be seen again, but i had my butt cheeks clenched and finger gripped on that thing so tight, i managed to get it to suck the other magnet out.  It was a victory for me last night.         
    • Yep, pretty much what you said is a good summary. The aftermarket thing just attached to the rim, then has two lines out to valve stems, one to inner wheel, one to outer wheel. Some of the systems even start to air up as you head towards highway speed. IE, you're in the logging tracks, then as speeds increase it knows you're on tarmac and airs up so the driver doesn't even have to remember. I bet the ones that need driver intervention to air up end up seeing a lot more tyre wear from "forest pressures" in use on the highway!
    • Yes, but you need to do these type certifications for tuning parts. That is the absurd part here. Meaning tuning parts are very costly (generally speaking) as well as the technical test documentation for say a turbo swap with more power. It just makes modifying everything crazy expensive and complicated. That bracket has been lost in translation many years ago I assume, it was not there.
    • Hahaha, yeah.... not what you'd call a tamper-proof design.... but yes, with the truck setup, the lines are always connected, but typically they sit just inside the plane of the rear metal mudguards, so if you clear the guards you clear the lines as well. Not rogue 4WD tracks with tree branches and bushes everywhere, ready to hook-up an air hose. You can do it externally like a mod, but dedicated setups air-pressurize the undriven hubs, and on driven axles you can do the same thing, or pressurize the axles (lots of designs out there for this idea)... https://www.trtaustralia.com.au/traction-air-cti-system/  for example.... ..the trouble I've got here... wrt the bimmer ad... is the last bit...they don't want to show it spinning, do they.... give all the illusion that things are moving...but no...and what the hell tyre profile is that?...25??? ...far kernel, rims would be dead inside 10klms on most roads around here.... 😃
    • You're just describing how type certification works. Personally I would be shocked to discover that catalytic converter is not in the stock mounting position. Is there a bracket on the transfer case holding the catalytic converter and front pipe together? If so, it should be in stock position. 
×
×
  • Create New...