Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Firstly, I don't need shit. I've been giving myself enough of it to last a lifetime.

For 10 years I've wanted to put spacers on my cars and never trusted them. Too many bad stories. But for some reason I thought I'd get some cheap Chinese ones from eBay to put in while I did Springs and shocks.

Well... I dropped the car back down and took it for a test drive. It started clunking from the rear within 10 metres from my house. I immediately did a uey and went back home. I found that 3 of the extra length lug nuts were finger tight. I pulled the wheel off with the expectation that my Springs were out of the mounts and I noticed the state of the spacer.

I had to heat it to get it off and beat the bejesus out of it with all sorts of tools but, here she is in all her glory.

I feel extremely lucky. I'll never use spacers again.

IMG_20200716_142200.jpg

IMG_20200716_142210.jpg

IMG_20200716_142216.jpg

IMG_20200716_142223.jpg

IMG_20200716_142226.jpg

IMG_20200716_142238.jpg

  • Like 2
  • Confused 2

looks bad, did you remember to give it a few extrra ugga-dugga's when tightening up the nuts with the rattle gun?

 

 

to be fair I think something else has happened here, perhaps that locating ring size was wrong?

I tightened it a lot. Rattle gun and then double check with the bar. I have a thing about lug nuts.

The locater trying was stuck in the rim when I took it off.

Ouch

31 minutes ago, PranK said:

But for some reason I thought I'd get some cheap Chinese ones from eBay

there's your problem...I don't feel like repeating myself from another thread, but cheap + china = no QC = playing Russian roulette 

  • Like 1

I have used many spacers over the years without a problem.  10mm is too much for slip on spacers...they should   be bolt on.. with the right combination of spacers and hubcentric rings should be fine. They need to be done up properly before putting any weight on the wheel.

Like Ben said what was the CB of the wheel and what were the inside and outside mm of the rings? The spacer looks like an odd diameter as well. The rings are soft - they are only made of aluminium - some are made of plastic. They are only meant to locate the wheels until you tighten them up.

Many aftermarket wheels have 73.1CB so to go on a Nissan the rings should state 73.1 to 66.1

 

yeah there was more at play here than just shit spacers (but don't be confused, those look like truly shit spacers). Centre bore looks to be an issue for sure. Spacers are't ideal but they aren't that bad. Have run them on my drift cars for years and never even had an issue. 

  • Like 1

I don't know enough about wheels, suspension or spacers to be of an use here, but glad that you only had this minor amount of damage. 
I shudder to think if it had let go at high speed... :( 

I am happy that you can post it up here though, sounds like you got off reasonably lightly all factors considered.

i'm not sure I understand the issue either; I used GK tech hubcentric issues with longer studs for many years with no issues, although agreed, never use uncentred " slipon" type/truly cheap sh^t. 

I had the " techs" at one Bob Jane outlet refuse to fit new tyres to my car because " I had spacers, and they're baaad, mmkay?"  I asked him if he realised they were hubcentric, and he truly had no idea what that meant. 

I've used 5mm non-hub centred ones in the past just to clear brakes. As long as you do your best to centre them properly/evenly before you fully tighten the wheel nuts, ive not had an issue. If its not centre properly I get slightly shakey steering wheel at 100kmh.
Switched to hub Gktech ones now and theyre not an issue.

Good thing you picked up on it Prank

Hey Christian, not sure if you ever got to the bottom of this, but I reckon the outer diameter of the raised part that was meant to slip inside your wheel was larger than the inside of your wheel. So, when you tighten it up the wheel nuts tighten down but the whole force was pushed onto the raised lip, not the spacer.

When the lip failed, all of a sudden your wheel nuts had 5mm of clearance and quickly departed.

If you take a wheel off and push the spacer onto the rear of the wheel; does it slide inside so the wheel surface and spacer are flat, or does the centre lip prevent that

  • Like 1

Thanks all,

So the spacer on the drivers side was fine. They both fit snug on the hub (and hub lip) and into the wheel. I plan on taking the passenger side wheel off this week and measuring the hub and the wheel to double check. I've held the two spacers against each other and they are identical in size.

I'll update once I've checked it out. 

I've found the spacers feedback in here to be interesting, I was definitely expecting a lot more anti-spacer attitudes.

 

  • Like 1
10 minutes ago, PranK said:

I've found the spacers feedback in here to be interesting, I was definitely expecting a lot more anti-spacer attitudes.

 

I think most of us are old and wise enough to know better than to come out swinging on this stuff. Sometimes we all make mistakes and sometimes sh*t just goes wrong. Live and learn!

*Plus we know you're not a troll and are always helpful... :)

11 minutes ago, PranK said:

I've found the spacers feedback in here to be interesting, I was definitely expecting a lot more anti-spacer attitudes.

You should have posted a pro-spacer thread in order to get that response here :P 

  • Like 1
15 minutes ago, GTofuS-T said:

You should have posted a pro-spacer thread in order to get that response here :P 

Not from me.

I've used lots of different "bolt on" spacers, from fleabay to brand name (fleabay items with a brand name painted on them).

Never once had an issue.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Very nice - I also have a 92 GTST and hardly see any others around these days
    • When I need something else to edit, I use Movavi. A friend who does video editing on a daily basis recommended me) it's an easy video cutter to use for beginners
    • I need to edit some videos for work but I'm not good at all this. Which video editor can you recommend?
    • I think you're really missing the point. The spec is just the minimum spec that the fuel has to meet. The additive packages can, and do, go above that minimum if the fuel brand feels they need/want to. And so you get BP Ultimate or Shell Ultra (or whatever they call it) making promises to clean your engine better than the standard stuff....simply because they do actually put better additive packages in there. They do not waste special sauce on the plebian fuel if they can avoid it. I didn't say "energy density". I just said "density". That's right, the specific gravity (if you want to use a really shit old imperial description for mass per unit volume). The density being higher indicates a number of things, from reduces oxygen content, to increased numbers of double bonds or cyclic components. That then just happens to flow on to the calorific value on a volume basis being correspondingly higher. The calorific value on a mass basis barely changes, because almost all hydrocarbon materials have a very similar CV per kg. But whatever - the end result is that you do get a bit more energy per litre, which helps to offset some of the sting of the massive price bump over 91. I can go you one better than "I used to work at a fuel station". I had uni lecturers who worked at the Pt Stanvac refinery (at the time they were lecturing, as industry specialist lecturers) who were quite candid about the business. And granted, that was 30+ years ago, and you might note that I have stated above that I think the industry has since collected together near the bottom (quite like ISPs, when you think about it). Oh, did I mention that I am quite literally a combustion engineer? I'm designing (well, actually, trying to avoid designing and trying to make the junior engineer do it) a heavy fuel oil firing system for a cement plant in fricking Iraq, this week. Last week it was natural gas fired this-that. The week before it was LPG fired anode furnaces for a copper smelter (well, the burners for them, not the actual furnaces, which are just big dumb steel). I'm kinda all over fuels.
    • Well my freshly rebuilt RB25DET Neo went bang 1000kms in, completely fried big end bearing in cylinder 1 so bad my engine seized. No knocking or oil pressure issue prior to this happening, all happened within less than a second. Had Nitto oil pump, 8L baffled sump, head drain, oil restrictors, the lot put in to prevent me spinning a bearing like i did to need the rebuild. Mechanic that looked after the works has no idea what caused it. Reckoned it may have been bearing clearance wrong in cylinder 1 we have no idea. Machinist who did the work reckoned it was something on the mechanic. Anyway thats between them, i had no part in it, just paid the money Curiosity question, does the oil system on RB’s go sump > oil pump > filter > around engine? If so, if you had a leak on an oil filter relocation plate, say sump > oil pump > filter > LEAK > around engine would this cause a low oil pressure reading if the sensors was before the filter?   TIA
×
×
  • Create New...