Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hello All,

I really want to get a dogbox H pattern, possibly a sequential, but I've been dissuaded by the servicing of said transmissions. I contacted Samsons to enquire about a RWD dogbox for my rb26 240z, but they told me their transmission need to be checked/serviced and rebuilt rather frequently.   Their response:

"Inspection of gearbox would be needed after 600-700km. Of course there are some drivers who inspect gearbox after full season and it looks like new, while other can damage dogs after 50km."

My question to the H-pattern dog and Sequential RB cars, how often do you service/inspect and/or rebuild your transmission?  

 

As above with the servicing, regular oil changes to keep an eye on any shedding of metal.. The most important thing to do is actually learn how to drive them, then dog wear becomes almost minimal.

I have an H pattern dog and basically have to drive around on the street like a truck - double clutch all gears and rev match. Simon Pfizer himself from PPG kept his H pattern dog in his own 32 GTR without the need to replace a single part after 20000km +, so it can definitely be done.

 

  • Like 1

I’m not sure how it is in Australia but in the US most long distance heavy duty freight trucks are still manual transmissions with no synchronizers. If they had to inspect the transmission internals every 600-700 km they would never be able to get their jobs done in a reasonable amount of time. It’s definitely heavily dependent on how good you are at shifting gears. If you can float gears smoothly with no drama you could probably go indefinitely with no replacement. If you’re learning on the transmission and making a lot of mistakes wear can be quite a lot and require short replacement intervals. Personally I know I’m not a pro at floating gears so I would go with synchros but if you are already double clutching every shift perfectly it’s not a far leap at that point to a dogbox. 

  • Like 2
On 01/05/2022 at 3:42 PM, joshuaho96 said:

I’m not sure how it is in Australia but in the US most long distance heavy duty freight trucks are still manual transmissions with no synchronizers. If they had to inspect the transmission internals every 600-700 km they would never be able to get their jobs done in a reasonable amount of time. It’s definitely heavily dependent on how good you are at shifting gears. If you can float gears smoothly with no drama you could probably go indefinitely with no replacement. If you’re learning on the transmission and making a lot of mistakes wear can be quite a lot and require short replacement intervals. Personally I know I’m not a pro at floating gears so I would go with synchros but if you are already double clutching every shift perfectly it’s not a far leap at that point to a dogbox. 

Trucks are same here - they come from the US. But yes pretty much what you said is spot on.

Good on the guys at Samsonas for being honest about living with a box like that. Keep in mind they would be assuming plenty of race, not street use in that estimate.

As the guys said above, I'd change the oil annually and look for sparkles. I'd take it out for a rebuild only if I couldn't regularly get a gear.

  • Like 1
On 01/05/2022 at 4:49 PM, BK said:

Trucks are same here - they come from the US. But yes pretty much what you said is spot on.

The gears in truck transmissions are huge, well they are in a R series Mack

We pulled a old Mack R series box to peices years ago for a look

We taught alot of people to drive in these, there was a huge amount of "cleaning the teeth in the gearbox" with the new drivers

Once they work out road speed, RPM and what gear their in, with a little rev matching and mechanical sympathy they are as quite as

Lots of fun taking off from a set of lights on a hill in a loaded Mack Dump with a trailer carrying a 15 ton bit of plant equipment

It's like tap dancing

I miss our old trucks

  • Like 1
On 01/05/2022 at 5:11 PM, Duncan said:

Good on the guys at Samsonas for being honest about living with a box like that. Keep in mind they would be assuming plenty of race, not street use in that estimate.

As the guys said above, I'd change the oil annually and look for sparkles. I'd take it out for a rebuild only if I couldn't regularly get a gear.

So far with dog boxes I've broken gears before dog wear has become an issue. I also used to run Quaife / Trust dog boxes frequently for years so that's not surprising.....

having a big Neodymium magnet on the drain plug to pick up metal in the sump of the box is a good idea.

the quicker you are with your shifts the longer the dogs will last.

an air shifted sequential with shift cut/blip > manual sequential > manual H pattern as far as dog longevity goes depending on your downshifting ability.

Edited by burn4005

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Meh, I think we're well into a new era of 90s JDM car. The days when spare engines and parts were cheap and plentiful are long gone. Therefore the YOLO approach is now massively difficult to justify, use and maintain. One should start to ponder whether an 800HP build is really justified, using stock parts. My thoughts? If you like/love the car and want to keep it and don't want to ruin yet another one, then be discrete about how much you ask from the stock parts. A 5 or 600 HP build is still a very fast car. If you want to go silly, have to have the 1000HP territory, then just drop all your cash, buy billet everything (or PRP cast block, etc etc) and use a bigger/more modern gearbag, and put a massive retrofit diff and axles into it. If you ruin any of those things then you're either ham fisted and deserve it, or you're pushing waaaay too far for the stock stuff anyway. The (presumably) young guys who are buying 30-35 year old busted arse Jap refugees and thinking they can live the life that was lived by others 20 years ago are deluded. Expectations need to be adjusted somewhat.
    • Just don’t be silly enough to think it’ll never happen either 
    • I take it that you bought the centre to suit the GTR axles? As in there was a plan, not just somehow lucky that it worked? It all looks excellent, by the way.
    • New engine block time. Up to you whether you want to keep going down this road with this project. Unfortunately a lot of these cars are like this. The road to getting these cars into decent shape is long and not fun for reasons that you're discovering. 
    • Essay time. First things first, an RB running stock turbo and boost levels shouldn't get so bad as to stall from reversion if the recirc valve has been deleted. Should get a little fluffy and annoying, but in my experience, not so bad as to stall. Of course, every car is a bit different, so it remains possible that stalling will happen. So, running with no recirc valve is somewhat of an option, for otherwise stock stuff. Atmo BOVs cause all sorts of shit, even on an otherwise stock setup. Only gets worse the higher the boost and the bigger the turbo. At that point you really need to go for a different ECU and no AFM. Rebuilding the stock recirc valve configuration is not hard. You just need a stock or aftermarket BOV with the appropriate adapter for the 2 bolt flange on the back of the J pipe, and to get/make an appropriate ~1" pipe to get the air back to the turbo inlet, and to possibly modify the inlet (if it is not stock) to take the recirc pipe back in. Not hard. Just takes some cutting and welding. Putting an R35 type AFM into the car anywhere is not as simple as just buying the AFM and throwing it in. You will also need to buy the appropriate boss that will then need to be welded onto the pipe where you're installing it. You can clearly see why by looking at the photo posted above. They are not a "simple" swap for a stocker. You can't put on in place of the stock AFM. You can put one in place of the stock AFM, if you get the mounting boss and weld it to some pipe and otherwise make that pipe piece work like the stock AFM housing. Or you can buy such an adapter, either complete with the 4 bolt flange for the air box, or without, for varying degrees of work needed to then make it fit your stock airbox or some pod filter or whatever you have going on. Oh, and the R35 AFM is not plug and play. The wiring is different, but changing that is trivial. The plug is also different so you either end up repinning the original wires onto the new plug, or you just use a short adapter. If you weld a boss to the cold side pipe, the cold side pipe really wants to be 3", otherwise the scaling on the meter can get a bit weird, but whatever the pipe size, it's not as easy as just using the (fully documented in the Nistune doco) simple method for choosing R35 AFM in X" pipe size in the software, because the scaling will already be a bit different. Anyway, all of this has been comprehensively worked through on the Nistune forums, so there is full knowledge available. I would use a Link/Haltech before I would bother putting an AFM into a cold side pipe. That's a lot of effort for a bodge. Nistune is great, can work well even at fairly high power levels, but you are stuck with the limitations of it being the stock ECU, which includes needing to use an AFM, which is not always convenient for every set of modifications. You have to have a think about what you already have, what you want to have, and decide early if you'd be better off jumping ship to an aftermarket ECU. This so you don't waste time and money doing things 2 or 3 times. Never heard of ECUmaster. Sounds like a backyard operation. If there are good tuners for it where you are, and it is a solid product, then it will be fine. We're only talking about an R engine here. Back in the day they all ran on crude nasty early 90s ECUs and they were fine. You don't need a rocket surgeon's ECU to run one.
×
×
  • Create New...