Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Yuh, so while I'm usually the guy explaining how the speedo and related shit works, I recently experienced something which blew my mind and I can't think of how it happened. So, I'm casting it out to the braintrust to see if there's any reasonable explanation.

Here's the story. I drove the car (R32 GTSt, R33 turbo gearbox) away from home, and the first time I noticed the speedo was once I was out onto the 60km road about 1km and 5 turns from home. I'm doing maybe 60 km/h. The speedo is reading ~120 km/h. I'm all "WTF is this?".

I roll down the road and out onto the 80km section, where the speedo is gleefully telling me that I'm doing at least 150, even though I'm pretty sure I haven't even caught up to the mix of sheeple and mad dream boats doing anything from 70 to 100. I accelerate to see what happens and the speedo happily winds off the dial at 180.

I stop at some lights. Take off, and......the speedo is back to normal.

The brain is doing about 500 km/h trying to work out how this could come about. The R32 speedo is a cable drive. The connection is purely mechanical, right up until you get to the spinny magnet and drum bizzo in the speedo head. It's not like there could be an electronic fault that was double sensing rising and falling edges of the waveform or anything like that. The cup in the speedo head had to literally be getting dragged around against its spring with enough force to make it read about double what was really happening.

So, has anyone got any brainwaves as to what the bloody hell could cause that to happen in the real, actual, physical world?

 

The speedo drive was built from a Navara drive about 10 years ago when the car's big birthday transplants happened. The drive cable is only a few years old, having snapped after ~25 years of service. The back of the speedo housing is hale and hearty, no bits broken off IIRC.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/484270-speedo-wtf-theories-please/
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, GTSBoy said:

Yuh, so while I'm usually the guy explaining how the speedo and related shit works, I recently experienced something which blew my mind and I can't think of how it happened. So, I'm casting it out to the braintrust to see if there's any reasonable explanation.

Here's the story. I drove the car (R32 GTSt, R33 turbo gearbox) away from home, and the first time I noticed the speedo was once I was out onto the 60km road about 1km and 5 turns from home. I'm doing maybe 60 km/h. The speedo is reading ~120 km/h. I'm all "WTF is this?".

I roll down the road and out onto the 80km section, where the speedo is gleefully telling me that I'm doing at least 150, even though I'm pretty sure I haven't even caught up to the mix of sheeple and mad dream boats doing anything from 70 to 100. I accelerate to see what happens and the speedo happily winds off the dial at 180.

I stop at some lights. Take off, and......the speedo is back to normal.

The brain is doing about 500 km/h trying to work out how this could come about. The R32 speedo is a cable drive. The connection is purely mechanical, right up until you get to the spinny magnet and drum bizzo in the speedo head. It's not like there could be an electronic fault that was double sensing rising and falling edges of the waveform or anything like that. The cup in the speedo head had to literally be getting dragged around against its spring with enough force to make it read about double what was really happening.

So, has anyone got any brainwaves as to what the bloody hell could cause that to happen in the real, actual, physical world?

 

The speedo drive was built from a Navara drive about 10 years ago when the car's big birthday transplants happened. The drive cable is only a few years old, having snapped after ~25 years of service. The back of the speedo housing is hale and hearty, no bits broken off IIRC.

Don't the R33 tachometers have a tendency to go completely crazy with age? Capacitors can lose their dielectric and basically turn themselves into a short circuit, dry joints intermittently making contact on inductive paths can pump up voltages beyond what's normal, etc. It's hard to say exactly what is causing it without really getting into the guts of it and reproducing/testing it but it's nothing beyond belief IMO.

9 minutes ago, GTSBoy said:

Apples and donkeys. The R32 speedo is mechanical. How does a spinning magnet in a cup turn the cup twice as hard as it usually does?

I can still think of a number of weird things that can cause what you saw. It's basically just an inductor at the end of the day. RF interference might do it if nothing is wrong with the circuit. If something is wrong with the circuit flipping an inductor off and on with a smoothing capacitor connected to a load is basically a classic boost converter. The flipping of the inductor off and on to ground is usually supposed to be controlled by a transistor but in this case it could be literally anything. Tin whiskers, that kind of thing. Only way to verify is to get it on a bench and see if you can reproduce with known input signals.

I get where you're going. My understanding is the cable spinning has a direct influence on the needle via magnetism right ? But it has to overcome the needle zeroing retaining spring tension to move at all right ? Only way I can explain is something, somehow that spring tension changed / decreased when it was bugging out. If that was the case at a real almost 0km/h car not moving but cable still spinning scenario, the gauge would have been not at 0 and deflecting around.

Apart from that, fked if I know.

Have had a similar issue in an old HQ. Turned out the drive cable spring had failed, never cut it open to see exactly but was doing random speeds most of the time and close to normal once in a while. 

5 minutes ago, robbo_rb180 said:

Have had a similar issue in an old HQ. Turned out the drive cable spring had failed, never cut it open to see exactly but was doing random speeds most of the time and close to normal once in a while. 

Could also be this.

29 minutes ago, GTSBoy said:

It's not a circuit! It is a spinning magnet dragging around a metal cup. It is a physical device. There are no electronics involved.

It's still a circuit, just a really simple one. The metal cup is technically an inductor.

On 12/12/2022 at 9:11 PM, GTSBoy said:

I'd have to be driving underneath one of the UFOs from Close Encounters of the Third Kind for that sort of inductive interference!

Were you? Typically these threads end up in a wild goose chase then information like that comes out at the end that explains it all.

  • Haha 2
14 hours ago, joshuaho96 said:

 

It's still a circuit, just a really simple one. The metal cup is technically an inductor.

I think he would argue its not a circuit - I would. A circuit would be current flowing through a conductor, an electrical connection between points. That's not what's happening here - there is no coil or wire with current flowing through it to move the needle, it's the eddy currents created purely by the magnet acting on the electrically conductive cup. Eddy currents do not flow in a circuit from start to end, they swirl around in a concentrated area in conductive material creating their own magnetic field.

Speedometer-diagram.thumb.webp.6aab3bbd46538982aadbbe11fed26b01.webp

That's why I mentioned the wound spring on the needle, which is a force to oppose this electromagnetism that moves the needle. If the force that moves the needle is correct, to me the.only way the needle to move further than intended is for the tension of the spring on the needle to decrease or slip allowing more movement.

That's the how a mechanical speedo needle could move more than intended, whether that's what's happening to this gauge, dunno.

just broscience brain here, somehow the speedo mechanism itself has been come overly magnetised from some huge inductor near by?

maybe it's 5G interference LOLOLOLOLOL... (this is a joke for anyone that thinks I am being serious).

  • Like 1

Yup, look for a mechanical fault around the hairspring assembly, it may have failed from age and causing the needle to read higher sometimes, or if there's debris or stuck grease around it.

Also UFOs do like to sight see around down undah so that's also a highly probable scenario. Don't know which part you're from but especially the coastlines around Western Australia are notorious for this. 👽

  • Like 1
1 hour ago, admS15 said:

Voodoo 

R32s definitely are cursed - broken speedo cables, a/c actuators that always stuff up, a/c vents made from plastic for maccas kids toys, interior door handles that turn to talcum powder, guaranteed dash clock deaths and the dreaded dash pad bubble.

2 hours ago, BK said:

R32s definitely are cursed - broken speedo cables, a/c actuators that always stuff up, a/c vents made from plastic for maccas kids toys, interior door handles that turn to talcum powder, guaranteed dash clock deaths and the dreaded dash pad bubble.

Sounds like you've described R33s too lol

43 minutes ago, Dose Pipe Sutututu said:

Sounds like you've described R33s too lol

No way ! Only thing I've ever had to do on that list in nearly 20 years on my 33 is the a/c vent mode selector actuator. None of those other things are an issue on a 33R generally but on the 32s it's almost guaranteed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Because all parts that are put into your papers usually are assigned a badging if they did not come with one. So other people can just check that badging to tell if it is the parts your papes outline. But my pipe has NOTHING on it whatsoever. No idea why this even passed as a Mines pipe to begin with. I see this going two ways: -nobody cares and it's a non-issue, but that is unlikely -the pipe will just have to be assigned a bagding, for sake of argument, a Mines logo, and the papers corrected accordingly If it interests you I will post what the actual solution ended up being. All I care about is that it has to sound equal length and nobody can screw me later on because of a pipe being illegal.
    • The fasteners to the pipe are not subject to TÜV I guess, if we really start putting nuts and bolts through technical tests I'm going to hang the people responsible and then myself. Usually on a modern-ish EU normed car, you would just replace the pipe. Because if you start hacking away at it and welding new pieces on the cops will definitely find a reason to tow your car. That is just how it is sadly. On old cars and imports with no clear "standard" stuff like that won't matter too much. Most cops or inspectors probably won't even really know what they are looking at. But there is experts for this stuff even among cops, and some of them know the rules to a T and even have extensive knowledge about many vehicles. For "just a pipe" to be legal it usually is included in a set of parts, like a complete intake kit or a full exhaust. For example my exhaust needs to pass a noise test, meaning they have a standardized test track with a set of instructions and they run the car through there 3x for an average noise value that is 75dB(a) at point x of the test track. If it's above that, fail. For a turbo setup to be put in your papers you have to do dyno runs, emissions testing etc. So quite costly
    • Would this not be the same for the exhaust you've posted up?  If your exhaust volume and emissions are fine, why does the brand of pipe matter? 
    • The issue is more the fact that there is inspectors that deal with japanese cars a lot and they might know what a real Mines pipe looks like. And then they're gonna get antsy and not pass your car. But I'd have to talk to one of them about this, because you know as well as me that it's just a damn pipe and it effectively doesn't do anything. As I need to have my GT2860s and my exhaust setup (and the increase in HP) TÜV'd anyways maybe they can just correct the entry in the papers or assign a badge to the front pipe. I'm no expert either though, will inquire about this.     Thanks for the insight. Not sure if having a custom made pipe is good or not. Will find out in due time I suppose. Would be kind of funny if this was made in Germany though.
    • See this is a really tricky topic as technically the same rules apply to all cars but for cars but there is a difference. If you want to modify a car like the Skyline which never existed here you have a bit more freedom as they do not adhere to EU specs anyway. Any modification you do has to be in dividually checked anyway so as long as one of the inspectors think it's ok and within the TÜV ruleset you can get stuff like a top secret rear diffuser put in your papers. Which frankly would need a shitload of tests and certificates for EU spec cars, like a 2010 BMW M3 for example. But if you DO run these tests and all tests come out ok (safety stuff for the most part) there is no problem running such a part legally. It's just way too expensive to do for a single person on one car. The most touchy parts are emissions related mods, like an exhaust, turbos, air intakes. If it makes noise or alters the carbon emissions it's essentially illegal until you prove it's not. Meaning it doesn't exceed noise limits or have worse carbon emissions. I'd say for hoses if you replace them same same it doesn't matter what material they are or what brand you use. Same for nuts and bolts usually, they won't go and specifically check that your water hoses and some bolts are 100% OEM parts, that is nonsense.
×
×
  • Create New...