Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Well it looks like i have a failed hydraulic lifter. Speaking to a few head reconditioners this morning it seems whilst its not common it can happen. Only prob is it seemg its next to impossible to by new RB20 hydraulic lifters :)

So since i have a spare 48, 24 from an NA head and 24 from my old head, can i get away with using 2nd hand ones? I guess so, but how do i go about testing/matching the best 12 (ill replace all of them on the exhaust side).

Thought of going to solids but the ppl i spoke to this monring said it would cost more then the engine to do so.... :Oops:

So who knows nissan engines parts lists, can i use RB25 lifters, RB30 ???? Whats available as when they recondition the head they dotn replace lifters, just valve seat and stem seals etc etc

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/49471-hydraulic-lifter-problem/
Share on other sites

whats wrong with the lifter ? very noisy ? did you have the cil head serviced recently ?

if you did thats the problem , you must bleed the lifters before you put them back otherwise they maybe noisy .

you could probably find the faulty lifter , or lifters , without taking them out , press on the lifter very hard it should not go down if it does its faulty .

if you are going to do it yourself let me know and i'll post how to test and bleed them .

i think all rbs use the same lifters but not 100 % on that as i havent cross changed them , you may want to check with nissan on that .

call neil at bob binks ford/nissan and buy some new ones...he is VERY helpfull for all parts

Thanks for the heads up, ill give him a try in the morning.

whats wrong with the lifter ? very noisy ? did you have the cil head serviced recently ?  

if you did thats the problem , you must bleed the lifters before you put them back otherwise they maybe noisy .

you could probably find the faulty lifter , or lifters , without taking them out , press on the lifter very hard it should not go down if it does its faulty .

if you are going to do it yourself let me know and i'll post how to test and bleed them .

i think all rbs use the same lifters but not 100 % on that as i havent cross changed them , you may want to check with nissan on that .

Well on cold start it makes brief tapping noise, about 1-2 seconds. Cold , warm it doesnt matter i can drive along at under 2800rpm with any throttle position and th eengine doesnt maek any noise, and the PFC engine light doesnt flash. At about 3,000rpm and light throttle openings a tapping noise from the exhaust side of the engine is easily audible.

If you keep your foot at over 60% throttle you dont hear the noise and the PFC engine knock level is normal...its only when you back off to change gear that there is a quick succession of tapping noise (Im assuming it is piscking up the mechanical noise, its not detonation)

So i want to do it myself, so if you could post up a bit of a DIY check and service of lifters.

The engine is a Jap import motor with only about 500kms on it since it was installed. It was running ok until a plug gave up the ghost and the ignition was missing badly for a lap or two at the track. I pitted, changed the plugs and went back out and the ignition miss was better.

Next morning at the track after a full tilt in 4th gear from about 4,800-7,000rpm for about 5 seconds (coming out of turn 2 at Phillip Island flat on the throttle up to brakes for Honda, engine light came on just as i was about to start braking) It was then that the tapping noise started....So thats the whole story.

I think im on the right track with an exhaust lifter, if you can think of anything else im happy to hear it. :)

Thanks for the heads up, ill give him a try in the morning.

Well on cold start it makes  brief tapping noise, about 1-2 seconds. Cold , warm it doesnt matter i can drive along at under 2800rpm with any throttle position and th eengine doesnt maek any noise, and the PFC engine light doesnt flash. At about 3,000rpm and light throttle openings a tapping noise from the exhaust side of the engine is easily audible.  

If you keep your foot at over 60% throttle you dont hear the noise and the PFC engine knock level is normal...its only when you back off to change gear that there is a quick succession of tapping noise (Im assuming it is piscking up the mechanical noise, its not detonation)

So i want to do it myself, so if you could post up a bit of a DIY check and service of lifters.  

The engine is a Jap import motor with only about 500kms on it since it was installed. It was running ok until a plug gave up the ghost and the ignition was missing badly for a lap or two at the track. I pitted, changed the plugs and went back out and the ignition miss was better.

Next morning at the track after a full tilt in 4th gear from about 4,800-7,000rpm for about 5 seconds (coming out of turn 2 at Phillip Island flat on the throttle up to brakes for Honda, engine light came on just as i was about to start braking) It was then that the tapping noise started....So thats the whole story.

I think im on the right track with an exhaust lifter, if you can think of anything else im happy to hear it. :)

are you sure its a lifter and not big and bearings ? if its a lifter it should do it more when cold big ends you will hear it more when hot ( thin oil ) cause when cold the oil takes up the slack ( thick oil ) , i hope its a lifter or 2 and not bearings .

anyway this is how you bleed hydrolic lifters : take them out put one at the time in oil ( it must be upright , hole on top and totaly covered in oil ) then you need a thin strong wire , thin enough to fit in the hole , while holding the lifter upright and totaly covered in oil push the wire in the hole hard so you push the valve down and with pumping action ( pushing down and leting it come up again ) keeep going until no more bubbles come out ( very tiny bubbles ) , when no more bubbles come out thats it they are done . to make sure they are ok push down on them very hard they shouldnt move down at all if they do they either got air in them or they stuffed . after bleeding them make sure you dont lie them on their side , keep them upright always .

good luck and if you want to know more just ask but it sounds like bad news i'm afraid to say .

Yeh its the check engine light, i am running a Power Fc and the flickering of the engine light corresponds when the knock indicator goes crazy...so its picking up the mechanical noise.

I thought about bottom end but stone cold it does it, warm it does it?!?!?! It seems to be audible from the top end more then the bottom end.

But you are right the load thing corresponding with the knocking/tapping noise suggests a bottom end bearing, and also the pace of the tapping. Cams only spin at half the rpm of the crank and the pace of the tapping noise sounds too quick to perhaps be a lifter.

Another scary fact is that the mechanics installed the engine with a big dent in the sump, my concern is that it could restrict flow around the pick up?!?!?! They say th edent is purely cosmetic?!?!?!?!

So there is plenty of reason to suspect a bottom end, but the noise does appear to be coming from the exhaust side of the head. Also the pitch of the knocking/tapping doesnt sound right for a big end.

Oil pressure seems fine, i would have thought if it was a bottom end problem, then by the times its audible i would have thought that oil pressure might be suffering by then...

Mmmm...so many variables, i think its best to start with the lifters and go from there.

Oh...another thing about the speed of the tapping noise. It would seem to be quicker then the rpm of the crank would allow, so likely to be several lifters....suppose the same could be said for a number of bottom end bearings...more then anything its the pitch of the sound that makes me thing lifters, its mroe a tapping noise then a knocking noise...that combined with my earllier mentioned observation re oil pressure

Oh...another thing about the speed of the tapping noise. It would seem to be quicker then the rpm of the crank would allow, so likely to be several lifters....suppose the same could be said for a number of bottom end bearings...more then anything its the pitch of the sound that makes me thing lifters, its mroe a tapping noise then a knocking noise...that combined with my earllier mentioned observation re oil pressure

you must be good to be able to tell the speed of the tapping noise .i wouldt go much on the speed of it , its easy to tell if its lifters or bearings , if you cant tell yourself take it to a workshop they will be able to tell you and so would i if i heard it . if iots a bearing it will get a lot worse and fairly quick too , it will stuff up your crank as well , so try to identify it fairly quick .

are you sure its just as loud when stone cold ? my guess is it would be quiter and the hotter it gets the louder it gets . how long sinse it started ?

you can have a stuffed bearing and still have plenty oil pressure .

what about if no 6 big end is gone ( thats the one that usualy goes ) and the piston hits the cil head ? then the noise will be on the top as well as bottom end .

roy i hope that its not a bearing , lifters are a lot cheaper than a total rebuild .

Ive had 2 cars that have done bottom ends, and only one engine with a noisy lifter. Would a high idle suggest a problem? If i disconnect the idle control valve it idles like a champion, only when plugged in it idles about 300rpm then the PFc setting. I dont think the issue is related.

There is absolutely no difference in the loudness whether cold or at operating temp. My only cncern if its a lifter, why doesnt it do it all the time, why is ut rpm and to a lesser extent load dependant

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Pfft. As if I'd ever point a high pressure washer at my car.
    • The nature of my commute has changed. Way back then it was traffic lights all the way, for ~28km. It sucked. When they finally stitched the expressway together I could do a good 15+km of it at a steady 80-100 with no stopping. That alone has gotten me down to flat 10s. Prior to that it was mid-high 10s. I can't remember the delta that I saw when I got the idle down. It was only ~150 rpm, because the idle speed was never terrible, but for the delta in consumption to be noticeable it would have had to have been at least 0.2-0.3 L/100km - which is not to be sneezed at when it comes for absolute free. It's only about 50L per year, but that's ~$100. A few extra pizzas is always welcome. Note that I have a record of every tank of fuel that has ever gone through my car except for a handful put in by someone else, like my mechanic. I can show you the difference between stock RB20 and tuned RB20, stock RB5Neo and tuned, winter and summer fuel blends, winter and summer fuel blends when the ambient temperature is not appropriate for the blend, working O2 sensor, blown O2 sensor, boosting f**k out of it and frightened to boost it because it is pinging, and so on. OK, I probably can't do all that now with 100% clarity - but at the time when any of those things were in event, you could see it in the records. There's 25+ years of simple tank after tank records, so you have to look for landmarks to work out approximately how old any single record is. What's really important is the meta data and that lives in my head.
    • If you're claiming the issues are not skyline specific, then either the USA is living in the 90s / early 2000s, OR you have the issue of "survivor bias". Which is you're mainly hearing and listening to those with terrible experiences, and haven't found the guys who have cars with good decent builds and no problems. It happens in AU too, that plenty of people keep having issues, and they keep going to the workshops that are known to be shit "because I read on the internet". Even worse, are those who keep posting on the internet as though they know for a fact what something is, when they've never touched/looked at said item in their life, and again are making assumptions, based on something they read, or because it's a certain way in other cars. It's even funnier when those same people debate the facts with the people who've lived and breathed this stuff for over 15 years. Example, I've had someone tell me you can't do something with a Skyline, because they read it on the internet, except I can tell they're wrong, as I did that exact thing back in 2008 with my Skyline.
    • The funniest part I saw, was someone would bitch and moan on FB about something, Andy would be the one to respond, asking for more info, if he could contact them, what the engine setup is, what their config file was, and 95% of the responses were people just going "der! It doesn't work" and Andy going "What doesn't work?" And then going "The firmware!" And they'd go around in circles as no one could ever give information, and Haltech couldn't fault things on the bench, (especially when people wouldn't give any specifics).   Many moons ago, when Andy was back at e420c stage, he reached out to me, and asked me to test different plug and play looms for him (already had an e420c in the car on his V1 PNP loom). And he kept asking me, as I was competent enough to be able to give him some specific feedback on what was/wasn't working, how to replicate the faults etc, and work through things with him. Most people are terrible at answering the questions they're asked, or being able to provide quality feedback other than "it doesn't work".
    • I say it often, none of this stuff is really Skyline-specific per se. But in general there's not a lot of people who actually know what they're doing. A lot of people charging like they do. Agile software development probably isn't the greatest idea for an engine controller.
×
×
  • Create New...