Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

$150 sounds about normal for safc type tune (piggyback). try ring unigroup

NewKleer, thanks again mate. always very helpful

:P

EDIT: let me just add, the quote i got over the phone was $400 !! My response was "O....K, i'll be sure to get back to you". (wont name the tuner, not unigroup)

Edited by Munkyb0y
  • Replies 1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

after reading about the tremendous success SK has had with the jaycar boost controller and FC ...i know which approach I want to take...but for the life of me I can't teach myself to solder ..or to tune a car.

after reading about the tremendous success SK has had with the jaycar boost controller and FC ...i know which approach I want to take...but for the life of me I can't teach myself to solder ..or to tune a car.

i can sell you my DFA, hand controller, connecting cable, and the jaycar performance electronics book if you are interested.

they are completely assembled but i no longer have any use for them as i am going the power fc route.

  • 3 weeks later...
  • 3 weeks later...
No more so than if the wastegate actuator vacuum hose falls off, splits or leaks. In fact, based on the reliability of electrical components in the cabin compared to rubber hoses under the bonnet, I would go the other way.

:/ cheers :)

If a tee was placed inbetween the solenoid and the wastegate actuator which had an orifice equivalent to the upper limit of boost you want to run and was fed from the inlet. Would this not provide the protection from excess boost? or am I now describing a parallel system.

Is there some problem with running these solenoids for extended periods at 100%? Are they notorious for overheating or are you just being cautious.

If a tee was placed inbetween the solenoid and the wastegate actuator which had an orifice equivalent to the upper limit of boost you want to run and was fed from the inlet. Would this not provide the protection from excess boost? or am I now describing a parallel system.

You are describing a parrallel system that would slow down the boost build. The fastest possible boost build is an advantage of the IEBC.

Is there some problem with running these solenoids for extended periods at 100%?

Nope

Are they notorious for overheating or are you just being cautious.

They are what is termed a normally closed solenoid ie; they LIKE being closed, it's their natural state.

:) cheers :laugh:

They are what is termed a normally closed solenoid ie; they LIKE being closed, it's their natural state.

I understood it to open as you apply duty cycle ie. 100% = open 0% = closed

I asked because I noticed that you were aiming for approx 60% duty cycle instead of 100%. That may bring back the slight surging you felt on the freeway when you needed a little throttle uphill. It would reduce your resolution by limiting the duty cycle to 60%.

I guess what I am asking is why do you wish to limit it to 60%

PS I think you have spent more time answering questions than it took to build, install and test the unit.

They are what is termed a normally closed solenoid ie; they LIKE being closed, it's their natural state.

1. I understood it to open as you apply duty cycle ie. 100% = open 0% = closed

2. I asked because I noticed that you were aiming for approx 60% duty cycle instead of 100%. That may bring back the slight surging you felt on the freeway when you needed a little throttle uphill. It would reduce your resolution by limiting the duty cycle to 60%.

3. I guess what I am asking is why do you wish to limit it to 60%

PS I think you have spent more time answering questions than it took to build, install and test the unit.

1. You got it. Most of the time I drive around on zero boost, so the solenoid is closed.

2. The surging was due to the R&R mapping of the ECU, tuning the SAFC fixed it

3. The 60% was the suggested target by SC, the idea being it gives you room to move up or down. If you are already at say 90%, then you don't have much room to move. BTW I am still running that table I posted last year (lots of 90% in there).

;) cheers :huh:

  • 2 weeks later...

SK - I have an Apexi boost control solonoid (you know how they work!)

Instead of it being plumbed into the common port and hooking up the normally open or normally closed for internal or external wastegates respectively - Doyou think it would work allright if you plumb boost pressure to the NC port, COM to the wastegate and NO as your vent.

Effectively when the solonoid is energised the boost pressure will be allowed to go straight through to the wastegate without any bleed off via the vent and when the solonoid is de-energised the traped air between the solonoid and wastegate can ecape via the NO(vent) port.

Works exactly the same but has no bleed off on boost.

The only problem I can see with this setup is that the size of the vent hole gouverns the duty cycle required!

Your thoughts would be most appreciated!

SK - I have an Apexi boost control solonoid (you know how they work!)

Instead of it being plumbed into the common port and hooking up the normally open or normally closed for internal or external wastegates respectively - Doyou think it would work allright if you plumb boost pressure to the NC port, COM to the wastegate and NO as your vent.

Effectively when the solonoid is energised the boost pressure will be allowed to go straight through to the wastegate without any bleed off via the vent and when the solonoid is de-energised the traped air between the solonoid and wastegate can ecape via the NO(vent) port.

Works exactly the same but has no bleed off on boost.

The only problem I can see with this setup is that the size of the vent hole gouverns the duty cycle required!

Your thoughts would be most appreciated!

Sounds OK, just whetever you are driving it with will need some duty cycle adjustment, but that's hardly unusual.

:) Cheers :banana:

Edited by Sydneykid

Gary, I believe the stock R33/R34 ECU's have self learning functions where they automatically adjust themselves when the car is driven. Given this, would the DFA (and other piggyback units such as e-manage and SAFC) have problems with the adjustments made by bending the voltages? i.e. if the ECU decides to change its values do the voltage benders constantly need readjustments?

the self-learning is mainly for the cruise conditions rather than open loop/power conditions you generally tune the DFA for. so i think, so long as you arent trying to change cruise condition operation (which wants the 14.7 or whatever ecu targets), any self-learning things shouldnt be too much of a interference.

might be worth datalogging the self learn alpha/base data from consult, but im not sure what the values represent

Gary, I believe the stock R33/R34 ECU's have self learning functions where they automatically adjust themselves when the car is driven. Given this, would the DFA (and other piggyback units such as e-manage and SAFC) have problems with the adjustments made by bending the voltages? i.e. if the ECU decides to change its values do the voltage benders constantly need readjustments?

Like newkleer said, the self learning only affects cruise conditions, whereas I know the SAFC only works on anything over 50% throttle, so the piggybacks do work well.

Not sure if the DFA works similar to the SAFC or not.

Gary, I believe the stock R33/R34 ECU's have self learning functions where they automatically adjust themselves when the car is driven. Given this, would the DFA (and other piggyback units such as e-manage and SAFC) have problems with the adjustments made by bending the voltages? i.e. if the ECU decides to change its values do the voltage benders constantly need readjustments?

You are describing closed loop running for constant throttle cruise and idle, which isn't "learning". They have a lambda target, usually 15 to 1, and they rely on the standard, slow and narrow lambda sensor to give feedback to the ECU. The ECU constantly adjusts the fuel supply to target that lambda. This happens at cruise and idle, being constant throttle postions. The standard, slow and narrow lambda sensor is too slow and too narrow in its sensing capabilty to work when the throttle is being moved or the conditions (up hill etc) are changing.

The SAFC, DFA or equivalent is over ridden (by the ECU targetting lambda) at times of constant throttle cruise or idling. But at ALL other times the SAFC, DFA or equivalent corrections to the AFM signals results in the ECU using different (than standard) load points. Hence leaning out/richening the A/F ratios and advancing/retarding the igntion timing. Simply put, as soon as you touch the throttle the ECU goes out of closed loop control and the SAFC, DFA or equivalent is in control.

:mad: cheers :D

The SAFC, DFA or equivalent is over ridden (by the ECU targetting lambda) at times of constant throttle cruise or idling. But at ALL other times the SAFC, DFA or equivalent corrections to the AFM signals results in the ECU using different (than standard) load points. Hence leaning out/richening the A/F ratios and advancing/retarding the igntion timing. Simply put, as soon as you touch the throttle the ECU goes out of closed loop control and the SAFC, DFA or equivalent is in control.

:laugh: cheers :sick:

Cheers Gary, good to hear. Would installing this DFA possible sort out my R&R problem? At 70% throttle at 5000rpm I hit a very viscous jerk that flings me forward then a second later the car accelerates only to have it happen again. I'm assuming this is R&R?

At flat throttle I can feel a few flat spots as well that basically makes the car feel very slow. Nothing as viscous as the scenerio above but noticable enough to realise that you aren't making full potential power. What could this be and could the DFA possible fix this as well?

Thanks!

  • 1 month later...

Hi SK'

i was wondering if you had any suggestions to my probablem. basically i bought a already built EBC and hand controller off some guy. But when i hooked it up, i didnt get any display, i opened it up and found out that a 10 ohm resister had blown, well i replaced it, and everything was fine, then later in the day, the display went out and the EBC stopped working, opened it up again, and saw the same resistor blown.

do you have any idea's why this might be happening

thank you

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Hello all I have 2 r34 sedans , one turbo one na, only recently aquired the na 34.  Man what is with these things.... My turbo 34 started sounding like a super charger, it was screaming at anything above 4000rpm , I took the alternator apart and replaced the front bearing which is the only one I think you can access and it did not fix the issue so presumably the bearing in the rear of the alternator is gone. ( diagnosed it was the alternator by taking off the aux belts one by one to figure out which pulley or bearing it was )  My friend gave me one he had lying around, Installed it , it did not squeal for maybe 500kms and now its started to squeal again briefly on startup  Recently got an na r34 and I replaced the timing belt, water pump + all the auxillirary belts. Runs amazing but it suddenly developed the same squeaking problem but significantly worse, Ive had my neighbour come down screaming at me because it was waking her up everytime I moved the car. It takes a good 2 minutes before it quietens down.  Im yet to diagnose where its coming from but im fairly sure its coming from the alternator aswell. My question isnt about how to fix it but rather where can you get a new alternator for an rb25 neo??? Ive searched everywhere but I havent been able to find a direct fit oem type replacement thats not genuine. All the automotive stores sell an oex one - BXA035 - which I picked up for cheap through a friend with staff discount , got it home only to find the connector is completelty different.... As far as im aware bxa035 is for rb20/30's and after a bit of figuring out the bxa035 has an ev14 type connector, which is tiny compared to the rb25 connector. I actually had an ev14 connector lying around which I was considering just replacing the bigger plug with to get the alternator working but the bxa035 is rated for 70amp vs the rb25 alternators are 90amp ( or so ive been told ? ) That paired along with the fact im about to install an amp + sub in the back and I have the stock sized small battery Im not sure itll do the job unless anyone has another opinion?  I know and have seen all the websites selling the ls1 alternator conversion kit but I am not going down that route, nor do I have the money to. Hopefully I can figure out how to get 2 brand new alternators for both cars. I would buy second hand which there seems to be many of but considering how common this seems to be im sure If I installed a second hand one it would start squealing in no time  Or even better if anyone knows how to fix the issue directly with the alternator itself... Any input appreciated Thank you     Link for bxa035 connector picture
    • As above, replace as many as you can afford. If anything, due to old age.
    • Can confirm previous shop that built my motor had no fking clue about oil control and caused my motor to shit itself after two track days. Current shop, Birrong Automotive, has managed to build me a motor, not to mention, has also let me tune it myself and it has yet to blow up after 7 track days. Great oiling success, yashimash.
    • It definitely seems like you have no beef, with only digging up a 5 year old post, to comment on an inflammatory item with total insensitivity, and of which had nothing to do with the thread.  Yep, you definitely seem like a great person and your friends and family would be so proud to know of your lovely actions
    • Thanks buddy, so happy to be back! Managed to pickup a Unicorn R34 completely stock and clean. Looking forward to adding some goodies to it and posting one here. I'm shocked that so many forums stopped. If you could find my old profile - I'd love that if its possible. My old account was JET200GT. My email might need to be fixed too. To use this one. I think it was the same though..
×
×
  • Create New...