Jump to content
SAU Community

Have you ever heard that cross drilled brake rotors crack? Here's the story...


Recommended Posts

From what I've heard the DBA rotors were drilled after they were fabricated? While the Porsche and other high-end rotors had the holes cast from factory?

Drilling post-fabrication gives less structural integrity doesn't it?

I could be wrong though..

If they are cast from factory, there is no reason why they would crack from the holes. They would have as much chance cracking from the holes as cracking from the outside perimeter of the disc.

Drilling certainly gives less structural integrity, it creates stress concentrations.

how do they explain that?? if theyre so bad for track work why do all hardcore racecars have em?

which hardcore race cars have cross drilled rotors?

Maybe the porsche carbon rotors but I assume they have different properties.

But what is wrong with good old slotted rotors, or even better nice, quiet, flat rotors for street use?

In airline use, there is a method of riveting where a big-ass pincher squeezes the metal so hard it makes a hole. Because the material isnt lost but is puched to the side, it reinforces the edges of the hole and makes it as strong as if there wasnt a hole there. There were numerous Airliners that failed due to metal fatigue like this. One where the skin of the plane split at passenger window and ripped open the top half of the cabin, and another one that opened up the luggage compartment because of cracking of fatigue on the rivets.

In airline use, there is a method of riveting where a big-ass pincher squeezes the metal so hard it makes a hole. Because the material isnt lost but is puched to the side, it reinforces the edges of the hole and makes it as strong as if there wasnt a hole there. There were numerous Airliners that failed due to metal fatigue like this. One where the skin of the plane split at passenger window and ripped open the top half of the cabin, and another one that opened up the luggage compartment because of cracking of fatigue on the rivets.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Latest Posts

    • Forgot to mention. I love the fact that Greg, Gregged Up, the model of his car, that has so many gregged up stories about its build! I had to have a little laugh. At the same time thinking "That's the sort of thing I'd do to myself!"
    • Not yet, might end up being easter now, didn't end up getting time off over xmas.    I've been seeing some concerning things online now too. Lots of people with issues, could all be setup issues but the consequences in some cases are significant.    All of the below are other peoples stories, not mine and are unverified.  Seen 2 x broken adapter ring that destroyed the gearbox as it failed.   They still do seem to have twin plate rattle despite claims of silent. Several issues with it not holding power but some evidence of constant pressure on plate. Setup issues with bite point.   Lot of people after 2-4 weeks swapping back to another brand.    On the positive side, I've seen a barra put down near 1000hp at the wheels and its held it.  Also everyone seems to confirm the pedal is light.    Does have me a little cautious and looking at ATS carbon clutches again .......        
    • I'm late to the party on this one but good to see common sense has prevailed and the turbo kit is coming. 
    • She's looking good Greg. Colour suits it perfectly 👍
×
×
  • Create New...