Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hi there...

i am currently lookin at purchasing a r32 GTR... but that is beside the point...

i am in a heated arguement with a friend over bang for buck between a r32 GTst and a r32 GTR...

his arguement is that u could spend the same amount of money on the rb20 and make the same power of that of an rb26..

my freinds arguement explained in this equasion...

cost of gsts + mods = stock GTR

now my arguement is why not buy a GTR and save maybe a few $$$ and have a better performance base... sure you will spend a bit more on mods but the overall outcome will be much greater...

cost of GTR + mods = THORPY SAYS ITS FULLY SIK!

now, to go slightly off track...

After stumbling across an old Zoom magazine, i read that 400wkw can be achieved in an rb26 by upgrading the turbo's, exhaust, ecu and injectors (and the other little things that go with it) and not really have to look at strengthening the engine internals....

would i be right in assuming a fair bit of modification would be needed to get a rb20 putting out the same power as a stock gtr?

i would just like to know cause i use to be a simple rotary owner who has "seen the light"... and i am sick of spending dead money on engine rebuilds.... :(

cheers

Cal.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/
Share on other sites

You are on the right track. A fair bit of money needs to be spent on top of the GTST to make similar power of a stock GTR and at the same time you losing on reliability.

Top power of RB20 is about 250rwkw and this is with all the support systems upgraded and an excellent tune.

If you have the money go GTR.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/#findComment-1332986
Share on other sites

Why upgrade the RB20? I bought an R32GTST, upgraded the suspension, wheels and tyres and stuck an RB31DET into it and it still cost less than half what a similar age and condition R32GTR would cost. Plus it weighs 200 kgs less and looses 20 rwkw less through the drive train. So a 400 kw R32GTST is much faster than a 400 kw R32GTR. And a 400 kw 3.1 litre engine is a damn site easier to drive/keep on the power/get off the line than a 400kw 2.6 litre engine. Plus with 200 kgs less and the same brakes it stops better for longer and doesn't overheat the tyres anywhere near as fast.

:(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/#findComment-1333022
Share on other sites

cheers guys...

sydney kid: that all sounds good... but i really cant be F$%#ed with having to screw around with hybrid engines (i'm guessin an rb31det is a hybrid)... as i am looking to build the factory engine... but it still sound tough :)

nedb: thanks for your input... much appreciated...

also, is geting about 400wkw in a GTR really as simple as they (zoom magazine) suggest? ie. upgrade exhaust, turbo's, injectors, ecu, intake......

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/#findComment-1333171
Share on other sites

Plus just think, would you prefer to be driving around in a GTS-T or a GTR? i can tell you know GTR has the respect. lets say two cars are driving through town next to each other ones a nuts GTS-T that can pump all the GTR's out there and ones a stock GTR everyone will be going look at that GTR, not look at that GTS-T.

Hell since ive bought my GTR i dont speed i give it a good thump every now and then but i sit a little below the speed limit and just cruise no one wants to race exept oter GTR's even cars i know would kill me they just stick there thumbs up and wave. so yeah go the GTR :bananaman

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/#findComment-1333225
Share on other sites

Id say just go the GTR...only thing is dont go trying to save a few dollars when purchasing it, get the best example you can find, as little things like tie rod ends, steering boots, bushes, brake rotors, fuel pumps etc etc will most likely need to be replaced as part of maintenance...not a GTR thing, just an age thing.

With a previous owner who has done these things then you are going a logn way of ensuring all other mechanical aspects are ok:)

Plus just think, would you prefer to be driving around in a GTS-T or a GTR? i can tell you know GTR has the respect. lets say two cars are driving through town next to each other ones a nuts GTS-T that can pump all the GTR's out there and ones a stock GTR everyone will be going look at that GTR, not look at that GTS-T.

Hell since ive bought my GTR i dont speed i give it a good thump every now and then but i sit a little below the speed limit and just cruise no one wants to race exept oter GTR's even cars i know would kill me they just stick there thumbs up and wave. so yeah go the GTR  :bananaman

lol...i love GTR owners, so many are like comic book heros:) And the same reason you like driving the GTR, id rather be driving my GTST, so swings and round abouts:cheers:

Its fine if its about the image or perception of performance, but so many stock GTRs are so tired and worn out that they will struggle to meet their factory performance claims, let alone that of a current performance car etc etc.:(

Sad thing is the same goes for GTST, though they are cheaper so easier to set straight:)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/#findComment-1333585
Share on other sites

Xmas 2004 i got my hands on my GTR and since then my hands havent been out of my pockets!!!

Just a personel thing, GTR looks good, drives great and cost a SH|T load. as soon as they know the part is 4 a GTR add 50% on what you originaly thought, Oh not to mention INSURANCE!!!

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/#findComment-1333611
Share on other sites

how much would all that cost for someone who didn't have your connections though SK?

I imagine the RB31DET would have cost a fair bit?

Whether we pay retail for a GTST and retail for a GTR or wholesale for a GTST and wholesale for a GTR it doesn't matter, the GTR will still cost twice as much. We have built 3 X GTR's to the same circuit race spec as the GTST and twice the $'s would be a bargain. It all mounts up, two LSD's instead of one, ATTESSA controller, extra clutch plates for the ATTESSA, 4 X lightweight drive shafts, 2 X lightweight tail shafts, a triple plate clutch (GTST has twin plate), Brembo callipers, Brembo rotors, transmission cooler, alloy winged and baffled sump etc etc

It doesn't cost more to build a RB31DET, it costs much less if you take into account the original cost of an RB30 versus an RB26. The reality is if I spend the same money buying and modifying an R32GTST, as I do buying and modifying an R32GTR, the R32 GTST will be faster. Ultimately, if I have enough budget, I could get the R32GTR to be faster but it would need to a pretty BIG budget

As for the GTR badge creedance......GIVE ME A BREAK..... 95% of the people who see my R32GTST think it's a GTR anyway. Even when it is parked with the 2 X GTR's.

:(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/72440-a-question/#findComment-1333636
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Pfft. As if I'd ever point a high pressure washer at my car.
    • The nature of my commute has changed. Way back then it was traffic lights all the way, for ~28km. It sucked. When they finally stitched the expressway together I could do a good 15+km of it at a steady 80-100 with no stopping. That alone has gotten me down to flat 10s. Prior to that it was mid-high 10s. I can't remember the delta that I saw when I got the idle down. It was only ~150 rpm, because the idle speed was never terrible, but for the delta in consumption to be noticeable it would have had to have been at least 0.2-0.3 L/100km - which is not to be sneezed at when it comes for absolute free. It's only about 50L per year, but that's ~$100. A few extra pizzas is always welcome. Note that I have a record of every tank of fuel that has ever gone through my car except for a handful put in by someone else, like my mechanic. I can show you the difference between stock RB20 and tuned RB20, stock RB5Neo and tuned, winter and summer fuel blends, winter and summer fuel blends when the ambient temperature is not appropriate for the blend, working O2 sensor, blown O2 sensor, boosting f**k out of it and frightened to boost it because it is pinging, and so on. OK, I probably can't do all that now with 100% clarity - but at the time when any of those things were in event, you could see it in the records. There's 25+ years of simple tank after tank records, so you have to look for landmarks to work out approximately how old any single record is. What's really important is the meta data and that lives in my head.
    • If you're claiming the issues are not skyline specific, then either the USA is living in the 90s / early 2000s, OR you have the issue of "survivor bias". Which is you're mainly hearing and listening to those with terrible experiences, and haven't found the guys who have cars with good decent builds and no problems. It happens in AU too, that plenty of people keep having issues, and they keep going to the workshops that are known to be shit "because I read on the internet". Even worse, are those who keep posting on the internet as though they know for a fact what something is, when they've never touched/looked at said item in their life, and again are making assumptions, based on something they read, or because it's a certain way in other cars. It's even funnier when those same people debate the facts with the people who've lived and breathed this stuff for over 15 years. Example, I've had someone tell me you can't do something with a Skyline, because they read it on the internet, except I can tell they're wrong, as I did that exact thing back in 2008 with my Skyline.
    • The funniest part I saw, was someone would bitch and moan on FB about something, Andy would be the one to respond, asking for more info, if he could contact them, what the engine setup is, what their config file was, and 95% of the responses were people just going "der! It doesn't work" and Andy going "What doesn't work?" And then going "The firmware!" And they'd go around in circles as no one could ever give information, and Haltech couldn't fault things on the bench, (especially when people wouldn't give any specifics).   Many moons ago, when Andy was back at e420c stage, he reached out to me, and asked me to test different plug and play looms for him (already had an e420c in the car on his V1 PNP loom). And he kept asking me, as I was competent enough to be able to give him some specific feedback on what was/wasn't working, how to replicate the faults etc, and work through things with him. Most people are terrible at answering the questions they're asked, or being able to provide quality feedback other than "it doesn't work".
    • I say it often, none of this stuff is really Skyline-specific per se. But in general there's not a lot of people who actually know what they're doing. A lot of people charging like they do. Agile software development probably isn't the greatest idea for an engine controller.
×
×
  • Create New...