Jump to content
SAU Community

Gettign sued...?

Pva_Glue

By Pva_Glue,
in General Automotive Discussion

 Share

Recommended Posts

  • 3 weeks later...
MR-GTR Enthusiast

MR-GTR

Posted
Posted

Hi everyone

]

Well if you organised a run and got everyone to sign a disclaimer then you are liable for any injury or death caused by an accident.

Under the current leglislation it would fall under "Duty of Care".

You see , you knew some one could get injured or killed on the run thats why you made them sign the disclaimer so you could have prevented it by cancelling the event, you would be held resposible for the injury or death, you are the organiser. You contributed to the injury or death by running the event and putting people in the position to be injured.

You see they could be out driving themself around getting killed on our roads and thats OK, you have gathered them on a run and organised them into a situation and possibly orchestrated their fate.

Now I'm starting to get confused !!!!!!.

this is the world we live in, be careful !!!!

And try and have a nice day.

ultim8DTM5 Experienced

ultim8DTM5

Posted
Posted
Originally posted by MR-GTR

Hi everyone

]

Well if you organised a run and got everyone to sign a disclaimer then you are liable for any injury or death caused by an accident.

Under the current leglislation it would fall under "Duty of Care".

You see , you knew some one could get injured or killed on the run thats why you made them sign the disclaimer so you could have prevented it by cancelling the event, you would be held resposible for the injury or death, you are the organiser. You contributed to the injury or death by running the event and putting people in the position to be injured.  

You see they could be out driving themself around getting killed on our roads and thats OK, you have gathered them on a run and organised them into a situation and possibly orchestrated their  fate.

Now I'm starting to get confused !!!!!!.

this is the world we live in, be careful !!!!

And try and have a nice day.

That is too broad, there are things such as the 'but for' test, which attempts to find as well as limit liability simultaneously.

ie: but for the cruise being held, would the incident have occurred? or is it but for the actions of the party at fault in an accident, would the harm have been caused? it would be the latter, duty of care revolves around whether the person organising the cruise was put in a position where there was a special relationship with the person suffered harm, quite arguble as in 'how was this duty different from other road incidents under the same circumstances, albeit organised?' was the actions of the tortfeasor (person at fault) were such where the harm suffered to the plaintiff was that reasonbly expected?

the only way this would come to be fully understood would be in each individual writ/civil case. disclaimers do not waive complete liability especially where there is negligence or other fault elements in failing to provide an adequate duty of care.

there is never an true and clear cut answer.

MR-GTR Enthusiast

MR-GTR

Posted
Posted

what your saying is very true, but in some cases it does come down to the person(judge) presiding over the individual case, here on the gold coast a person left a hotel bar intoxicated on foot, crossed a road 80 mtrs away and was hit by a car, the plaintiff sued the hotel and the bar tender for "Duty of Care". was awarded $1,600,000aus .

Basically the staff should have known there was a chance he would be hit by a car as he was drunk when he left the hotel. it was deemed their fault he drunk so much and got drunk and got run over.

beets me !!!

Do you know of any crazy outcomes.

Regards

Steve

Duncan Grand Master

Duncan

Posted
Posted

Another one I loved, from a soccer club around the corner.

Lady gets drunk, staff stop serving her and offer to get her a cab home. She refuses, screaming/yelling, gets escorted out. Then opens the bottle she had bough earlier from the bottle shop, gets even drunker.

Walks onto road out front, gets hit by cab.

Sues club for not giving "duty of care". Wins.

Everything is someone else's fault these days

puckish Rising Star

puckish

Posted
Posted

Hmm Since we are not a club as such but just a group of people who contact each other over the web then we are not a collective so to speak, so who are they gunna sue? Not the cruise organiser as he is not responsible for the person driving (or trying to drive) nor the other vehicle that may be at fault.

Honestly who could be held responsible for the fact that someone else caused there own death due to their stupidity.

The reason cigrette companies were sued was that there product could only have been satistically correllated to the death of smokers. Silly ......but true.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Latest Posts

    • GTSBoy
      City of Casey - This is obscene!

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      There's a thread over on PF.com where this has already been beaten to death. I make this point only because the report that you're referring to is already out of date. They have walked back some of the silliness, including the need to apply for (and risk losing the application fee, if not granted) a permit to work on your own car on your own land. But there is still a lot of silliness left remaining. Victoria is a f**king shithole. Has been since way before we started calling it Brackistan. f**king nimby woke Stalinist nightmare of a place.
    • Watermouse
      Stock rb25det neo questions

      By Watermouse · Posted

      I’ll go last point, For me it’s, can I do better relying on the expertise of u experts in the field but my point was, is there a way and a will to sticky important tried/true/tested facts that come out of a question relating to each area of improvement. I mean like not losing valuable info when u end up relying on google without success. Some times. I just see so much knowledge being passed but unless u are a guru or lucky, the diamonds end up hidden in our forum sorry guys I’ll leave it at that respect 
    • PranK
      Cleaning my wheels 😍

      By PranK · Posted

      Oh, and despite all the links, there's nothing sponsored here. Paid in full by me. 
    • PranK
      City of Casey - This is obscene!

      By PranK · Posted

      What the actual f**k is this about?  https://www.carexpert.com.au/car-news/this-australian-city-wants-to-charge-people-to-work-on-their-cars A $400+ permit, every 3 months, to work on your own car?  Tell him he's dreaming. 
    • Kinkstaah
      Mistakes were made, my R34 Story

      By Kinkstaah · Posted

      I did a bit of googling, the color MCM used was Galaxy Grey from House of Kolor. This is actually a colour I picked out about ~10+ years ago (or more). This one is a stock BMW colour, I guess over the years I figured it was smart to get an OEM colour that was pretty common for all of those sensible reasons one can think of..
×
×
  • Create New...