Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Ok so just want to hear everyone's opinions really.

Im looking at upgrading from a stock ECU in my R32 RB20 and playing with the idea of either of these really. Obvisouly the pro's and cons of each and what have you found out with each one.

At the moment the GReddy E-management looks better as its a cheaper option but want to get as much out of my car as possible and now as im building it up for drift i want to have tune ability as well without causing mega head aches.

Cheers in advance for any reply's

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/77062-power-fc-or-e-management/
Share on other sites

easy one, click below. Your sure to find all your answers pretty easily, and considering there is a sticky in this section about one... wont be hard

:)

Here?

NO its not pretty easy, i have already searched the forums and had a read of the "sticky" at the top of the page with the E-management.

What i want to hear is peoples feedback on both, so before you go and try and be a smartarse and post in one of my threads read the question first, i want to know what people think, pro's and con's of what people have experienced with either one.

You want to be a smartboy fark off and do it in someone else's thread of send me a PM :chairshot

Threads below took me exactly 2 mins seconds to find.

Dont be rude or warning points will be coming your way.

These threads aer only a quick find by myself.

If you really want to kknow more im sure another few mins will answer what your asking

THREADS:

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

http://members.dodo.com.au/paul/doc...powerfc-faq.htm

And here is one VS a Mictotech as well

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

And even a Mines ECU

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

Threads below took me exactly 2 mins seconds to find.  

Dont be rude or warning points will be coming your way.

These threads aer only a quick find by myself.

If you really want to kknow more im sure another few mins will answer what your asking

THREADS:  

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

http://members.dodo.com.au/paul/doc...powerfc-faq.htm

And here is one VS a Mictotech as well

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

And even a Mines ECU

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/sh...rFC+vs+E-Manage

LIKE I SAID i had done a search and went through a lot of threads, including the ones that you ever so nicely linked above.

I realise it has been covered but some of the threads that i had been reading were from not that long ago and i figured that rather than posting up in an old thread i would like to get peoples opinions and thoughts in a new one, that is relevant to what im asking and to my needs, not piggy back on someone else's thread.

Why be an arse and make out you are the only one that know's how to search??? I searched previous to posting this thread and did not get what i was looking for. Therefore posted asking a question :confused:

You want to send warning points or what ever it is you do then if that makes you feel happy go ahead, but understand it from my point of view.

Im looking for answers and your trying to make me look like an arse, like i said before send a PM and tell me your thoughts or if im doing somehting wrong when posting a thread, or give me your opinion on the topic and question.

I dont mean any disrecpect to you at all R31Nismoid and i know you got a job to do but maybe look at the way you go about things in the future, cause at the moment your coming across as a keyboard warrior that has no personality

I hear what you are saying about the two but they are both different types of after market comps I had the Greddy E Manage in my previous car which is totally different from the Skyline.... after the people were able to wire the GReddy and then get it working correctly it worked great we were able to get the car to drive very reliably and very economically whilst still being able to exract every bit of h.p available... I think the hardest thing for most people is to be able to find someone (tuning house) that has set up a GReddy into a Skyline previously otherwise it could cost you more money in setup time. My car still retained the factory ecu as it is only a piggy back but it also has the ability of being like your home p.c were you can upgrade programs and components like adding the Pro-Fec... the people that did my car also used the GReddy for there twin turbo magna and this car drives so nice almost like a factory car just with a bit more power.

From what I can understand from the PFC is that it is a plug and play which is good and that you will lose the 180klm speed limiter which also sounds good if you are into track racing, it will also give you a good tune and economy, but you will also lose some of the nicer things that the factory unit provides like the HICAS and I think a few other things... but this is a full replacement ECU with a few limitations.

I think I will end up getting a GReddy for my R33 due to how impressed I was with it in the Lancer and how much range we had with the tuning of it in RPM points... good luck with your choice it is not always an easy one

how do you loose HICAS?

i still have HICAS on my car.

HICAS (as far as i kno) has a totally separate ECU in the boot.

Can you please state what other things the stock ECU (save for the HICAS) that a PowerFC does not?

im interested to know indeed

A-LSD is the only incompatibility that I know of when comparing powerfc to stock ecu. Everything else I've seen works fine. This only affects RB25DET powerfc. The RB26DETT powerfc doesn't have any problems with the V-Spec A-LSD

I hear what you are saying about the two but they are both different types of after market comps I had the Greddy E Manage in my previous car which is totally different from the Skyline.... after the people were able to wire the GReddy and then get it working correctly it worked great we were able to get the car to drive very reliably and very economically whilst still being able to exract every bit of h.p available... I think the hardest thing for most people is to be able to find someone (tuning house) that has set up a GReddy into a Skyline previously otherwise it could cost you more money in setup time. My car still retained the factory ecu as it is only a piggy back but it also has the ability of being like your home p.c were you can upgrade programs and components like adding the Pro-Fec... the people that did my car also used the GReddy for there twin turbo magna and this car drives so nice almost like a factory car just with a bit more power.  

From what I can understand from the PFC is that it is a plug and play which is good and that you will lose the 180klm speed limiter which also sounds good if you are into track racing, it will also give you a good tune and economy, but you will also lose some of the nicer things that the factory unit provides like the HICAS and I think a few other things... but this is a full replacement ECU with a few limitations.

I think I will end up getting a GReddy for my R33 due to how impressed I was with it in the Lancer and how much range we had with the tuning of it in RPM points... good luck with your choice it is not always an easy one

cheers for the post, just one thing though what are you basing the loss of the HICAS on??? I know a couple of people with Power FC set ups in there R32's and none of them have said anything about HICAS loss???

And to tell you the truth i dont really need/want the HICAS as im building this up as a drift car :uh-huh:

A-LSD is the only incompatibility that I know of when comparing powerfc to stock ecu. Everything else I've seen works fine. This only affects RB25DET powerfc. The RB26DETT powerfc doesn't have any problems with the V-Spec A-LSD

i have a locked diff at the mo and was planning on getting rid of it but now that i want to get into drift that will be staying there.

The Power FC i would be install is for a Rb20 so this shouldn't cause any problems with that should it paulr33???

nah you should be fine grandmasterb, the r32 didn't have A-LSD.

"but this is a full replacement ECU with a few limitations."

Would love to know what the limitations are.. ?

yeah i realise it doesn't have a LSD and i really want to know the limiations that people keep talking about mainly for the R32 gts-t, that was kinda the point with this thread really, as i read so many others and none really covered that point at all.

yeah i realise it doesn't have a LSD and i really want to know the limiations that people keep talking about mainly for the R32 gts-t, that was kinda the point with this thread really, as i read so many others and none really covered that point at all.

Based on my experiences there aren't any real limitations, I have seen Power FC equiped cars make over 1100 bhp, I have seen Power FC equiped cars do low 8's for the 1/4. Personally I have an R32GTST with a Power FC that has 420+rwkw and it runs better than it did when standard. We also have an R32GTR and an R34GTT and all of them have Power FC's.

On the other hand the E-Manage is a piggy back, most Skylines have problems with the ignition tuning, they cook coils, won't run, won't start etc. As a piggy back it has all sorts of compromises and areas of tuning that it can't access, that the Power FC does. As for being cheaper, not when you add up all the extras you need to half way tune a Skyline.

There is simply no comparison grandmasterb, don't waste your time, buy a Power FC and get on with it.:thumbsup:

I am sure I read somewhere that there were certain things that the PFC did not do or was not designed to do but it also depended on which version of PFC that you got... I am really sorry I can't be more specific than that due to the amount of stuff that I had read about the PFC... all that I can remember is that there was something to do with the HICAS or LSD...

The ignition and injector cables that are required for the GReddy will cost an extra $150 - $200 on top of the original $600 for the unit and as far as the tuning software and cables it is better to use a place that is experienced with the GReddy as they can be a bit tricky for most to use

Based on my experiences there aren't any real limitations, I have seen Power FC equiped cars make over 1100 bhp, I have seen Power FC equiped cars do low 8's for the 1/4.  Personally I have an R32GTST with a Power FC that has 420+rwkw and it runs better than it did when standard.  We also have an R32GTR and an R34GTT and all of them have Power FC's.

On the other hand the E-Manage is a piggy back, most Skylines have problems with the ignition tuning, they cook coils, won't run, won't start etc.  As a piggy back it has all sorts of compromises and areas of tuning that it can't access, that the Power FC does.  As for being cheaper, not when you add up all the extras you need to half way tune a Skyline.

There is simply no comparison grandmasterb, don't waste your time, buy a Power FC and get on with it.:D

Yeah i here what ya saying Sydneykid and cheers for the reply. I was talking to the local place that i got a quote off and he said that the Apexi Power FC unit that they get in is not capable of deleting the AFM, does this sound right??? :confused:

I was also quoted $1050 to me in Tassie with the H/C

I am sure I read somewhere that there were certain things that the PFC did not do or was not designed to do but it also depended on which version of PFC that you got... I am really sorry I can't be more specific than that due to the amount of stuff that I had read about the PFC... all that I can remember is that there was something to do with the HICAS or LSD...

The ignition and injector cables that are required for the GReddy will cost an extra $150 - $200 on top of the original $600 for the unit and as far as the tuning software and cables it is better to use a place that is experienced with the GReddy as they can be a bit tricky for most to use

its cool just curious thats all, as i would like to know these things before i buy that way im not left scratching my head

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • best advice yet.  so between the elite and the nexus... much of a difference?  cost is damn near identical (only $170 difference).  thank you!!!
    • Hi everyone, I've found some free time to write up my "build thread" which is 10% 'build' and 90% fixing problems of a skyline that has endured a lifetime of abuse. I will start with the backstory & get everyone up to speed. Ever since I was just a teenager in high school I have had a spot in my heart for the shape of an R32 rivaled only by the look of an S13, my mates & I all having overly ambitious dreams as one does about having the sickest car in the school carpark. Unfortunately I started my journey of cars down the path of the Silvia and after spending years of putting up with the underwhelming SR20 life I dipped my toes into the 1J Toyota pool for a small moment until my true compass brought me back to that incomplete dream of an R32. At this point the trawl through marketplace, gumtree, carsales etc. starts looking Aus wide for an affordable example in the current economy which was extremely barebones compared to the good old days of sub 10k cars everywhere. Out of the handful of cars in the budget at the time I settled on a 1992 R32 GTS-T that was located in Adelaide. It had caught my eyes as it was similar price to the others on the east coast and had been RB25DET NEO converted and an open door respray in a custom colour based off TH1. It was also a stand out to me because it already had some NSW registration left which saved me the hassle of getting it on the road in my state. As for mods I was told it was pretty stock other than the motor swap, a nistune to run it, and an unknown fuel pump. My first mistake was trusting the seller blindly that the car was in good condition in all aspects and decided to purchase the car unseen other than some walkaround videos & pictures as the flights down there were very expensive at the time. The price of getting it transported to my door from Adelaide from Sydney was surprisingly cheaper than the flights at the time. I was told the few issues it apparently had was only 1 speaker not working, some cracked or missing trims, and it had been rear ended at some point but had been all professionally repaired (this is all foreshadowing at this point). I paid for the car, and then booked the interstate transport. Now at this point save your criticism as I already know how stupid I sound in hindsight, this was a major lapse of judgement and I accept the problems that followed. I spent the next 2 weeks in a crazed excitement knowing I am finally the owner of an R32 & that it was on its way. I started preparing as when negotiating with the seller I opted out of the Lenso wheels as they aren't really my style & I wanted a set of genuine wheels, and the bucket seats in the car as I am 6ft5 and not the skinniest guy so I had my predictions that I wouldn't fit in them anyway. Due to this the car was put on a set of R33 stockies and some average condition R33 seats that he had laying around. While I waited for the car to arrive I went and picked up a pair of R32 seats and some R32 GTR wheels to fit nicely on it once it had arrived. Being the first time I had done anything like this or had a car transported interstate I had no clue how the logistics of it were, I chose my work as the delivery address assuming it would arrive at some point in the middle of the day. You can imagine my surprise when I wake up to a call from the truck at 5:30am telling me his about 20 minutes away. When I tell you that was the fastest drive to work I have ever done, I managed to catch up to the truck before it even got there. Spent the hours before work taking in the car and living my first experience with one, I had never even been inside one so I spent some time getting familiar with the interior before doing the seat swap. Here is my first proper photo of it as the sun rose in the background. I also noticed it had the switch for the electronic front lip which was a pleasant surprised but sadly upon looking it didn't actually have the lip or the motors or even any wiring behind the switch. As I swapped the seats, the extremely questionable history of the car started to show itself starting with some really dodgy seatbelt buckles that had been extended for some reason with horrendous welds. This was followed by me noticing the drivers side front was quite bent up to which the owner then decided to let me know it had been hit in the front at the same time as the rear end. It also had a pretty leaky power steering rack and the pump was screaming for its life. By now I was a little on edge but I had to get to work for the day, I sent the car down to my mechanic to get the fluids changed and a general check over as I started to question what I had got myself into. I packed the GTR wheels into the car to get put on while it was there as I ran out of time which was a struggle because the handle to release the fuel door/boot was non-existent and just had the end of the cable tied to a bolt. It wasn't much of a surprise when I got a call saying that it looked like the fluids hadn't been done in quite some time. Although that didn't come as a shock, it did catch me off guard when I was told he couldn't open the boot which had the wheels in which I just had open not long before. Mission #1 was to squeeze through the back panel and open the boot from the latch while loaded with a set of wheels which to my amazement he pulled off after a bit of a struggle to reveal there was nothing holding the cable mechanism in place where it sits at the fuel cap. After that dilemma was solved the mechanic did an inspection over the car while on the hoist with nothing too interesting being found other than the expected crushed frame rails. It seems to have had some bilstein shocks installed at some point and judging by the AWD sump that has been sealed up I suspect the NEO is out of a stagea. By the time I got the car back and was ready to have my first drive home in it I was still excited but now quite anxious with the car already. First stop was to the servo to get a nice fresh tank of fuel as I had no idea how long it may have been sitting around for before I bought it. It sat quite nicely on the GTR stockies I must say. Now my drive home from work is short only being a 15-20 minute commute so the chances of anything going wrong is quite small right? WRONG. As I go over a speed bump only 100m from home I start to smell the dreaded smell of electrical burning and my lights drop out and shortly after the car dies. I am in extreme panic at this point thinking the car is going to burn down on its first drive before I have even had a chance to insure it. I move to the bonnet as quick as I can and lift it up, and as I go to grab the bonnet prop my brain is in such a frenzy that it takes me a second to realise my hand is being burnt to a crisp. This is where I notice that there is no plastic clip for the bonnet stay and when I have gone over the speed bump it has knocked the stay onto the positive terminal of the battery welding itself there. Levering it off with a nearby stick I sat there for a few minutes making sure nothing was going to burn down while waiting for a mate to come jump start me. My main stress was that I could've absolutely cooked the ECU or any other electrics. I was relieved when the car started fine with jumper leads on it but it would die as soon as the headlights were turned on so I carefully limped it home with no lights and decided it was a tomorrow task. You can see here where the stand sat on the positive terminal. Thankfully with a new battery the car behaved and seemed healthy. It was pretty smooth sailing for a little while getting to enjoy dailying the car. Interior wise it was pretty much as the seller described except for the the lack of working speakers, the digital controls had no power, and the headunit would randomly turn off & on. I installed a quick release I had laying around from an old car to help with getting in & out of the car and a nice momo wheel. I bought some oem side skirts to match the rear pods that were on the car already, who said a skyline can't be a practical parts mover. Test fit looks good! Found a good deal on a GTR wing & boot that I couldn't turn down. At this point the skyline was being too good to me and had to throw the spanner in the works again. First incident was as I was coming off the motorway and heard a bang and an awful grinding noise. As I pull over down a side street to investigate I notice my whole exhaust has basically fallen off and is dragging on the ground. After waiting around to let it cool to the touch I managed to get it back on its hangers. Thinking it was a weird 1-off instance I didn't think much of it until it happened to me again a few days later to which I see this time the middle hanger has snapped in half and the rear hangers have snapped at the welds. I manage to get the car in to a shop to get the hangers welded and while there I notice that my intercooler has broken its brackets and was being held up only by the piping. Quickly got that sorted and got some thicker brackets out of steel plate to support it all. Just when you thought at this point the car might give me a break, I fill the car up on my way home from the fabricators shop and after I pay I walk back to a good portion of my liquid gold on the floor. I just shrug it off at this point in exhaustion and call it a job for another day. The car had other plans for me though as the next morning on my commute to work, I am halfway there when I notice I am struggling to shift gears. I get lucky with a run of no red lights to work and find some time on my lunch break to investigate the problem. The slave wasn't leaking and the master still had fluid so I was left confused until I contorted myself under the dash and noticed the whole pedal moving loosely side to side when pushed in. Upon pulling it out of the car I found it to be multiple snapped spot welds on the clutch pedal bracket and the actual face of the pedal that sits against the firewall had snapped in half. I jerry rigged it with nuts & bolts at the spot welds but I will need to come back to this in the future and replace with one of the strengthened nismo brackets available. I then got to enjoy the car for another 2 months of cruising and dailying it, peep the obnoxious fireballs it would shoot every shift on the dodgy tune that was on there. On a sunday drive in that period of working car, I was on my way home on the motorway when I heard a slapping noise on my front left to which I pulled over to find my indicator had ejected itself from the car. Nothing a bit of tape can fix lol. I then bought some smoked indicators but after I realised I didn't like the look I found some damaged series 1 indicators. I repaired the tabs with some cut up cards and they looked good to me. My next venture was the hunt for some wheels, I test fit my mates Work Equip Spinning that were tiny 15" and I wasn't sold on the small wheel look. I ended up finding a killer deal on some Rays Volk Racing Group C in 17x8.5 & 17x9 that had been rebuilt many years ago and not ran on a car. I am still yet to get these on the car as they require some specific adapters and shank style lug nuts but I think they will look awesome. At this point my 2 months of reliability had ran out and on a cruise with some friends I suddenly lost the ability to shift gears again and thankfully could get it home by taking main roads and not having to stop. This time my master cylinder was bone dry and the culprit was the clutch slave that had decided to let go. It was a quick and fairly easy fix, but in my luck bad things always come in waves. Only a few weeks later I am on my way home from World Time Attack when the car completely shuts off while coasting down a hill, I try crank it while I still have momentum but no luck. Thinking I might have killed the fuel pump from running it low or maybe killed a CAS because the symptoms seemed to line up somewhat, I opt to get the car towed to a workshop to get fixed up on the Monday. When it gets there they get stuck into diagnosis and the CAS wasn't sending a signal to the ECU, and the fuel pump was also dead so it was comical for a small moment there. They replace the dead fuel pump when one of them notices some smoke coming from the passenger kick panel. Boy oh boy this is where it gets very bad and very expensive. I am not sure who wired the car when the NEO swap was done originally but I hope they never attempt auto electrical again as I am lucky that this handywork only managed to short and kill the ecu and engine loom and not do more damage. This is the point where you could say the 'build' started but not by choice. After some deliberation with my bank account I opted for a Haltech Elite 2500, RB terminated loom, and WB1. While I wish I stopped there and did the minimum of get the car running and leave it at that, I slipped into the rabbithole and decided I wanted to make the most of getting a retune and throw some bolt ons at it and see what it would do. I then threw together a bit of a mix n match build of marketplace deals starting with a GCG GTX3076R, a turbosmart FPR6, 980cc injectors, walbro 460, jackspanian ffp, throttle & fuel rail. At this point it was coming along nicely, the shop was making quick work of it and the bay was looking a lot nicer without the stock crossover intake. I also got them to replace the noisy centre bearing while it was off the road. Then we couldn't get an OEM CAS to talk to the haltech so ended up getting a PRP Street Trigger Kit for it.   While the car wasn't playing nice it decided to kill the stock alternator too so went with an LS1 alternator conversion kit. By now the car was pretty much done and ready to go but come tune day the car kept throwing the timing out every time it would warm up. Upon further investigation it seemed to be warping the PRP trigger bracket when the metal would get hot and expand which would cause the sensor to lose timing as it moves. Herman advised that they have seen the issue a few times now and don't know what the cause is. At this point I decided to switch to the PRP Pro kit with the crank trigger and considering the whole timing belt would have to come off I decided to get a new timing belt kit with water pump fitted. The car would now run fine with no issues and it was finally tune time. It ran up a healthy 275kw but ran out of boost due at 17psi to the rear housing being undersized. At this point the clutch also started slipping and due to it still being a weak RB20 box the tuner set it up to ramp from 8psi up to 17psi with the revs so that it wouldn't load up the clutch and box as hard. Car drives like a dream now. With the car back on the road I could return my focus to the smaller details, starting with getting a set of badges for the hood and quarters. I was struggling to drive with shoes on and I noticed that my accelerator pedal sits higher than my brake and clutch, if someone could confirm how it should sit that would be great. Next little changes was a killallwipers rear windscreen wiper delete, I also got some interior bits I was missing such as parcel shelf speaker covers, wiper trim cover, and boot floor and trims. Finally made it to a SAU NSW event which was awesome to cruise with a bunch of likeminded individuals. Another creature comfort I decided to look into was my lack of A/C. Since the Haltech got wired up the digital climate would power up now, and would blow but no cold air. First issue noticed was the lack of belt on the A/C compressor. After sorting that to no avail, it also had no A/C gas in it, but turns out the condenser has a huge leak. We are almost caught up on the story so far, but at the start of this month while coming into a driveway I heard a huge clunk in the front end to which I got out to witness whatever dodgy camber arms someone installed in this at some point decided to snap in half and I feel very lucky that it didn't happen at speed. Managed to get the car fixed the next day with some replacement GKtech arms. Next problem to address was the leaking gas tank from months ago. Checked the pump hanger seal first but that was fine, stuck my camera up after filling up to try scope out the leak which looked like the breather hose. Got the car up on a hoist prepared to drop the tank when I reached up to feel with my hand and I could feel that the hose clamp was missing and soon after felt that there was a gaping hole in the top of the hose. Replaced and tested and the car holds its liquid now and doesn't give me a fume headache whenever I drive it now. Finally have caught up and now onto fixing my latest issue which is the lack of dash light when driving at night, checked fuses first, then when searching I found the common problem of the headlight switch burning out but mine looks fine. Next test will be plugging a known working headlight switch into my car to tell if my switch is dead. Sorry for the long read but I wanted to be thorough, so if anyone made it this far I salute you soldier. Enjoy the rest of your day and I will keep this updated with issues I find/solve and any cool mods I can do inbetween. Merry Xmas!
    • can someone tell me what information a block number of 330680a on a rb25det engine specifies?
    • Would you suggest staying with a twin setup but upgraded turbos  ?
×
×
  • Create New...