Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hi all

Thanks for the great feedback on my previous thread about clutches.

Just got one last thing on my mind right now.

What is the differences between the different amount of pucks on the single plates ? Ok I know the physical differences as Ive seen them for myself....just wanna know the theoretical applications.

Say theoretically, with all things equal. The following clutches were installed on the same car with same driver and same power at all times.

Single plate 9 puck

single plate 3 puck

Twin plate

Which one would last the longest ?

Heard some say twinplates dont last that long compared to singles then the other night a mate swears that his friend wore out a 3 puck single plate in 6 months !!!!! which has got me a little concerned as I have already ordered the 3 puck single ceramic for my car :)

:)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/78391-clutch-questionagain/
Share on other sites

The more pucks the better!

The more surface area you are covering, the less over all wear.

There is alot more strain and wear on 3 pucks then on 9 pucks of equal size, thickness and compond.

The same goes for twin plates, as this states, there are 2 plates of pucks then just the one.

Hope this helps

ok so would a 9 puck hold just as much power as a 3 puck ??

or would the 3 puck hold more ?

If the 3 puck does hold more wouldnt it balance out in the end ?

ie 9 puck wont be able to hold the power and hence wear out at a faster or equal rate to the 3 puck.

If we are talking about the same clutch and the difference is 3 or 9 puck, well the 9 puck will hold more as long as it is the same size, width & compond as the 3 puck.

When you have more of it to grip with, it will hold more power. Because you have more surface area eg. more pucks - there is more compond to grip the flywheel and pressure plates

Ok.

Please dont take this the wrong way cause im not doubting your knowledge.  

But if we go by your theory shouldnt a full face clutch be better than any "puck" clutch ??

I mean what are the advantages of having the pucks then ?

Yeah you have a point there, When I was replacing the clutch the guys that make them here in Adelaide told me that a clutch with pucks will do better than a full face (performance wise), the full face will be more friendly for day to day driving.

So interested to see who is right here, cause I got a 5 puck one.

If the full face clutch was made with the same compond material as the puck type cluches well it would be better. Most of the time it comes down to manufactering costs. There is no point in placing more pucks or clutch compond if increases the price and does not suit the market intended for.

If you look at a Nismo twin plate clutch, they have almost a full face clutch with the puck style compond which is made up of ceramic compond. The reason for the gaps is heat and the ability for some flex. because these use a large ceramic pad (puck) they are more expensive.

I rang Adelaide Clutches (Xtreme) as they can replace the ceramic pads on them. I almost fell over when then gave me the price, think it was like $1200.00

Reason - it was almost a full face with just some slits in them.

If the clutch was manufactured to hold say 300 HP and it does this with 3 pucks of ceramic pad then way had more? If you added more the clutch price would increase and so would the rated HP.

Another thing you could do is increase the puck's surface area by adding more and decreasing the pressure plate force. You get a softer clutch with the same HP rating but this would cost more as manufacturing costs have also increased.

If you think about it, a twin plate works by have more pads on more metal, silimar to say like having 2 fly wheels and 2 clutch plates. The pressure plate does not have to be very high as there is already alot of compond in contact with metal. Not saying the pressure plates in twin plates are always soft but in the case of the Nismo twin plate, they get a high HP rating cause they use a full face clutch with a medium pressure plate. These are some of the reasons why it holds good power and is light on the foot and behaves like a stock clutch.

Yeah you have a point there,     When I was replacing the clutch the guys that make them here in Adelaide told me that a clutch with pucks will do better than a full face (performance wise), the full face will be more friendly for day to day driving.

So interested to see who is right here, cause I got a 5 puck one.

I think the terms full face might be misunderstood here.

Is the full face made of the same compond as the 5 puck one?

Usually the full face they speak about is made up of similar compond used in stock clutches but the puck version is made up of ceramic compond. In this case the 5 puck one will do a better jop performance wise.

I think the terms full face might be misunderstood here.

Is the full face made of the same compond as the 5 puck one?

Usually the full face they speak about is made up of similar compond used in stock clutches but the puck version is made up of ceramic compond. In this case the 5 puck one will do a better jop performance wise.

So if you put a full face and a 5 puck made out of the same material, whatever this may be, the full face one is gonna do better than the 5 puck? :confused:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Yep it's an r34. Usually people remove struts without removing the front upper control arm (fuca is what i assume this is?) So not sure why mine wouldn't fit. I know on my other car I did a similar job and it wouldn't fit until I removes the ball joint nut even though I didn't remove it prior.   The upper arm doesn't seem to be in the way (the part that's bolted to the chassis. The part that's bolted onto the j arm I'll check that out though.   I was going to compress the spring and put it in with the compressor attached but not sure if it will work  Haven't seen anyone do it.
    • I have a small lip on the boot of the E90 and I've been toying with the idea of trying to mould it in to the boot to remove the gaps. I guess shaving the seams? No idea what the terminology is here.  What I'm wondering is, if it's current double sided taped down, what would I do to more permanently attach it so it makes a good base for the filler? It only has edges so no way to bolt it down unless I add some braces. I've done a lot of fibre glassing in my time so that's nice and easy but I'm not sure what my options are here.  Sorry, this is the best pic I have and I'm 4 million ks from home ATM.  
    • Based on this comment I went googling. A052's in the sizes I want are certainly not cheap, but I couldn't find anything in the V70A anywhere. How much do they run/where do they get sourced from? From what I know (nothing but internet searches and reviews etc) the R888 has pretty much fallen off from anyone's actual use, and the AO52 is the king of "road legal" rubber. Nobody is driving around on their daily for Z221, AO050, DZ03G. At that point, for purely track only tyres - Why not buy actual slicks? Why does nobody actually do that anyway?
    • This an R34? It shouldn't matter though - it should be the same as on any of the others, and by "any of the others" I mean R32, because that is the car that I have had the front end apart on about 50 times this year. Sometimes, it is much easier to get the lower shock eye onto that pin when: a) you have the upper shock nuts backed off a few turns so you can wiggle it a bit more freely. When they are tight the bottom of the strut is much harder to move that _leeeetle_ bit you might need it to to win the fight. b) you have the outer bolt(s) from the FUCA out and so you can move the lower pin around freely too. Then, all you have to do is put the upper arm back on when you've got the rest back together, and this is where jacking under the balljoint can help.
    • One question before I make a bigger mess potentially, do I need to undo the nut on the outer ball joint? 
×
×
  • Create New...