Jump to content
SAU Community

What so good about rotary????


Recommended Posts

A few people i know seemed to have changed with the wind and are now on the rotary band wagon and i dont know why.

Whats the pros and cons with a rotary engine over your normal 6.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 41
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

i own one, also own a 32 gtr, and i love it but i really cant answer your question without writing an essay, and i cant be bothered, they get crap fuel economy tho

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i own one, also own a 32 gtr, and i love it but i really cant answer your question without writing an essay, and i cant be bothered, they get crap fuel economy tho

They can handle big massive turbo's with minimal turbo lag!

They rev high when ported and modified.

They sound so great.

They have shit fuel econemy

They are very light

They sit back in the firewall, good weight distrubution

They are cheap to fix

There is jack shit to modifiy on them

Thats about all...

Ill be buying one soon :Pimp2:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

my interpretation is thus: It is very similar to the 4 stroke, 2 stroke debate, as rotary's operate as essentially a 2 stroke. Thus while they can burn a lot more fuel per second, and hence get more power, they do so inefficiently. This has become a problem with changes in emissions regulations. However practically you can get a lot of power out of very small displacements, and hence get fantastic power to weights. Similarly because of the large amount of fuel they can burn, they couple with turbo induction very very well. A typical downside is things like that the whole central rotor has to move, and so there is a lot of friction wear on the seals, which has given it a bad reputation (I think) for reliability. Overall many companies and individuals worked on the rotary concept (mercedes, nissan to name a few) however only mazda continued for such a long time (rather like wankel). They certainly have some great positives, but also a number of downsides, which is perhaps why they have never been largely taken up. That's just my rough overall summary of rotaries :P.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm in the exact same position as you Lang!

Although I'm off-loading my RX7 for an sr20 180sx X-Type, hopefully, this week.

For me, the 7 was a fun, quick, sidways car. Love the way it looks from the front, hate the back (series 5)

Lang is spot on, they drink! Also I have found that they are very high maintenance, so cbs with it anymore. BUT, they have very high modification potential, hence their popularity and I suppose there's something about a rotary engine that draws people towards it, that I just can't put my finger on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

my interpretation is thus: It is very similar to the 4 stroke, 2 stroke debate, as rotary's operate as essentially a 2 stroke. Thus while they can burn a lot more fuel per second, and hence get more power, they do so inefficiently. This has become a problem with changes in emissions regulations. However practically you can get a lot of power out of very small displacements, and hence get fantastic power to weights. Similarly because of the large amount of fuel they can burn, they couple with turbo induction very very well. A typical downside is things like that the whole central rotor has to move, and so there is a lot of friction wear on the seals, which has given it a bad reputation (I think) for reliability. Overall many companies and individuals worked on the rotary concept (mercedes, nissan to name a few) however only mazda continued for such a long time (rather like wankel). They certainly have some great positives, but also a number of downsides, which is perhaps why they have never been largely taken up. That's just my rough overall summary of rotaries :P.

2mm Ceramic seals can fix that problem :D

New,good seals should last upto 100,000klms with a high powerd engine running sufficient boost levels.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

people are scared but they don't understand or have sufficient knowledge, explaining how a piston engine makes power is easier to ur average joe then explaining how there a chamber with a triangular shape thing in the middle which sits on an eccentric shaft and rotates thru a epchyotroidal (spelling) revolution and makes power 3 times per revolution.......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the main reason why rotoarys got a bad reputation of reliability is because thed mazda service folks would replace the whole engine instead of replacing the broken part. My house mate has a mazda RX3 which still running and has never needed a rebuild.

The other reason that the have an unreliable name is that they can very easily run hundreds of KW's and like any engine need to be very well built to witstand the force. A dodgy 6 will still die as 500kw if it is dodgy.

In their stock condition they can be fairly efficant and the RX8 is one of the cleanest cars for emissions. The old ones aren't because they are before the times off emmision control and therfore no cat etc.

The engine is very small and very simple (only 3 moving parts). Because if goes around and around instead of up and down they can rev much higher then a piston engine up around 12000rpm if you really want to.

They are great for turbo's as the engine moves alot of air. This allows for monster turbos on a 1.3L engine.

Overall they are a great engine to work with as long as you have apassion for them and you know what you are doing with them.

Igonr: Each rotor will have 3 power "strokes" per revolution. The 10a, 12a and 13b have 2 rotors so that is 6 power "strokes" per revolution of the engine. A piston has one power stroke every 2 revolutions. Therefore a 12 cylinder piston engine will have the same number of power strokes as a 2 rotor engine. If you move to the 20b (3 rotors) or 26b (4 rotors) then your going to have more power then you know what to do with.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Igonr: Each rotor will have 3 power "strokes" per revolution. The 10a, 12a and 13b have 2 rotors so that is 6 power "strokes" per revolution of the engine. A piston has one power stroke every 2 revolutions. Therefore a 12 cylinder piston engine will have the same number of power strokes as a 2 rotor engine. If you move to the 20b (3 rotors) or 26b (4 rotors) then your going to have more power then you know what to do with.

Interesting... thanx for that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A few people i know seemed to have changed with the wind and are now on the rotary band wagon and i dont know why.

Whats the pros and cons with a rotary engine over your normal 6.

I own a bridgeport RX4 coupe and an R31 GTSX . The skyline is a great cruiser for everyday travel.Its even got a child seat in the back.Economical and goes pretty hard(r32 silver top engine).The RX4 is brutal!!!! Heaps of grunt from the Weber fed 13b(turbos go so much harder too!) But the best thing is the sound.Love it or hate it every one knows you are coming and boy do they look.(Coppers too!).

Fuel economy is shithouse(advise getting 2nd job) especially when you realise that we are talking about 12A(1200cc) and 13B(1300cc) motors.To make good power ie;200 rwk from a rotary costs a lot less than a 6cyl.Check out how fast they go at the drags.Sub 7 sec passes in O.Z!!!!! Some bent 8 cars spent 30 - 40 thou to run 10sec 1/4 times.10sec eng packages for rotarys from about 6 - 10 grand.And still streetable with programmable engine management.Thats why there are so many cars on the track!

The price of a good car is still affordable, remembering most are 30 + years old(unless you have lots of dough to buy late model RX7's).Parts are available for most but more and more expensive all the time.(check ebay.)RX3 is the most popular and buying one is an investment you won't loose from.The price of import skylines has fallen pretty hard lately,old rotary cars have increased.

A lot of people(Simple minded neanderthal types)write off rotary cars because they have never driven one or have had their ego dented by one in a traffic light drag.Typical Holden or Ford V8 fans call them by heaps of names "chook cookers" "beer kegs" and just "jap crap".I could go on forever but you have probably already stopped reading by now anyhow.

By the way, my R31 GTSX is up for sale!!! Not the RX4though.Love the Skyline but need the dough for a new bussiness.If interested call me on 0405 202 395.Wazza.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

every time the engine performs one revolution, it combusts 3 times. that's good for power.
And what does a 6 cylinder in-line do??????

The main advantage of the rotary is that the "piston" (rotor) mass keeps moving in the same direction, unlike a "conventional" 4-stroke, in which the piston has to stop twice in each cycle (once at TDC, and once at BDC). So rotaries just keep revving. which is why they can make big power numbers (power = torque * rpm). They have pretty shite torque, but loads of rpm. (diesels on the other hand have enormous torque and shite rpm, but that's )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share




  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Well, yeah, the RB26 is definitely that far off the mark. From a pure technology point of view it is closer to the engines of the 60s than it is to the engines of the last 10 years. There is absolutely nothing special about an RB26 that wasn't present in engines going all the way back to the 60s, except probably the four valve head. The bottom end is just bog standard Japanese stuff. The head is nothing special. Celicas in the 70s were the same thing, in 4cyl 2 valve form. The ITBs are nothing special when you consider that the same Celicas had twin Solexes on them, and so had throttle plates in the exact same place. There's no variable valve timing, no variable inlet manifold, which even other RBs had either before the 26 came out or shortly afterward. The ECU is pretty rude and crude. The only things it has going for it are that the physical structure was pretty bloody tough for a mass produced engine, the twin-turbos and ITBs made for a bit of uniqueness against the competition (and even Toyota were ahead on the twin turbs thing, weren't they?) and the electronic controls and measuring devices (ie, AFMs, CAS, etc) were good enough to make it run well. Oh, and it sounds better than almost anything else, ever. The VR38 is absolutely halfway between the RB generation and the current generation, so it definitely has a massive increase in the sophistication of the electronics, allowing for a lot more dynamic optimisation of mapping. Then there's things like metal treatments and other coatings on things, adoption of variable cam stuff, and a bunch of other little improvements that mean it has to be a better thing than the RB26. But I otherwise agree with you that it is approximately the same thing as a 26. But, skip forward another 10 years from that engine and then the things that I mentioned in previous post come out to play. High compression, massively sophisticated computers, direct injection, clever measuring sensors, etc etc. They are the real difference between trying to make big power with a 26 and trying to make big power with a S/B50/54 (or whatever the preferred BMW engine of the week is).
    • Is the RB26 actually that far off the mark? Honestly from where I'm sitting a VR38DETT is not actually that much more advanced than the RB26. Yes, there is a scavenge pump on the VR38, it's smarter in a number of ways but it's not actually jumping out to me as alien technology. Something like a B58 or V35A-FTS on the other hand has so many surprising little design features that add up to be something that just isn't comparable. 
    • https://www.carsales.com.au/cars/details/2021-nissan-skyline-400r-auto-rv37/SSE-AD-17857548/ Well there you go 
    • Chris won't reply. He doesn't visit the forum much anymore. You can try these guys https://www.facebook.com/autotainment/ They did mine many years ago
×
×
  • Create New...