Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

I cant see why when on highway cruising the engine should be on boost. It should still be in vacuum when maintaining steady highway speeds for sure...

Btw I still reckon you can stay with 14.7 AFR for boost upto approx 5-7 psi underneath 3500 rpm. I know that my standard ECU (S14 SR20DET) does this, with no qualms.

At cruise, it isnt on boost at all, i think he is meaning accelerating to 100 but then again i can accelerate there with no boost.

Sorry, I worded it badly. I didn't mean on open constant throttle on flat road meant you were in positive manifold pressure, I meant at normal cruising, you will go up and down hills unless it's the nullabor or something. Up a hill the turbo can start to come on boost which will make the fuel economy suffer more than it otherwise would. I didn't mean to say that it's always on positive boost constantly at 100kph+. Also I'm sure it doesn't need to be in positive pressure to be using more fuel, just slightly less vacuum than NA would have a similar effect. Even the extra bit of back pressure keeping the turbine spinning will have a slight cost on the engine efficiency. Nothing is free.

My understanding is that ultimately the airflow decides final fuel economy, as the signal given to the ECU predicates what load cell to use, which in turn is translated to the INJ map so this decides how much fuel to dial in. It shouldn't have anything to do with boost or if the turbo is spinning or not. I can cruise along at 2500rpm with my foot hardly on the pedal and airflow meter may say 2.4v if I keep my foot the same and being to drive up an incline engine load will increase (despite thorttle sensor the same) and as a result, more boost may be built up, this will also move the map cell as airflow meter load increases.

Boost driving fuel economy would only be an effect on a map sensor ECU

Airflow driving fuel economy will be the driver on an airflow ECU

if that makes sense? (sorta)

I cant see why when on highway cruising the engine should be on boost. It should still be in vacuum when maintaining steady highway speeds for sure...

Btw I still reckon you can stay with 14.7 AFR for boost upto approx 5-7 psi underneath 3500 rpm. I know that my standard ECU (S14 SR20DET) does this, with no qualms.

Thats correct they do stay closed loop until about 7psi of boost pressure however the standard ECU has a time at load until additional enrichment function as well. This way if you just coming onto boost for a bit and then back off it will stay closed loop to save you feul however if you are on boost for too long cylinder temp sky rocket. This is why they introduced this function.

And paulr33 I still very sceptical on your aiming for 15:1 AFR as the PFC doesn't have a lean cruise function. Do you turn the 02 sensor feedback on once your finished?

hey guys,

just installed my pfc and my engine check light is on. what the go with that? any help would be great.

The FAQ (in my signature) clearly outlines why the engine light would be on for a new install

yes i turned 02 feedback back on. why?

what should i have done instead?

i will be hopfully getting it again soon to recheck them

currently going to struggle to make 300k's to a full tank of city driving

GO FIGURE!!!!

yes i turned 02 feedback back on. why?

what should i have done instead?

i will be hopfully getting it again soon to recheck them

currently going to struggle to make 300k's to a full tank of city driving

GO FIGURE!!!!

If your mixtures are around 15:1 AFR open loop and you command a closed loop AFR of 14.7:1 then the O2 sensor slowly trims more and more fuel until it reaches 14.7:1. The further from stoic you open loop mixtures are the more it has to trim and you using more fuel this is why the call it feedback as it waits for a conditon and then trims.

What you want to do is tune as close to stoic as you can, this way the O2 sensor will have very little trimming to do.

Alternatively you could just turn off closed loop and tune whatever you want.

Is there a map or chart / guide i can look at to suggest some AFR's to aim for when wideband tuning. i have an AFX guide which i had a look at it and also some comments on the forum

idle load 16 afr is ok

light load 15 afr is ok (upto say around 70km/h - 80km/h)

around 100km/h aim for 14.7

i wont be touching any full load or WOT

merely light load / cruise

1) turn off 02 feedback

2) plod around and check out the 02 wideband values

3) fix speed at 30kmh light load then dial it to be around 16.5afr

4) fix speed at 50kmh light load then dial it to be aroudn 16.0afr

5) fix speed at 80kmh light load then dial it to be around 15.5afr

6) fix speed at 100kmh light load then dial it to be around 14.7afr

the reasons for my afr aiming are engine safety based on heat, keep the afr lower near 100kmh to keep the exhaust heat down and down kill the valves (thanks gary for that tip)

any comments / ideas / feedback / criticism welcome as im doing it tonight

If your mixtures are around 15:1 AFR open loop and you command a closed loop AFR of 14.7:1 then the O2 sensor slowly trims more and more fuel until it reaches 14.7:1.  The further from stoic you open loop mixtures are the more it has to trim and you using more fuel this is why the call it feedback as it waits for a conditon and then trims.

What you want to do is tune as close to stoic as you can, this way the O2 sensor will have very little trimming to do.

Alternatively you could just turn off closed loop and tune whatever you want.

so is the idea to tune as close to 14.7 as possible and have 02 feedback on and just deal with whatever economy i get or to tune the light load / cruise areas to say near 15.5 ish (as listed above) and then have 02 feedback off permentantly as ive dialed in my own afr's?

so is the idea to tune as close to 14.7 as possible and have 02 feedback on and just deal with whatever economy i get or to tune the light load / cruise areas to say near 15.5 ish (as listed above) and then have 02 feedback off permentantly as ive dialed in my own afr's?

If your happy enough with your mixtures and dont worry about accelleration enrichments then I would leave the O2 sensor off otherwise enable the O2 feedback and tune as close to stoich as possible.

I would say once your happy with your timing numbers dial in the say 13.5:1 at zero boost and hold it at constant load. If after a sustained load at this boost it introduces a higher knock figure on the PFC then enlean the mixtures futher until the knock numbers start to increase. This is the point at which the chamber temps are sufficiently high to cause detonation so you richen it up just a little to reduce cylinder temps.

For a standard cast bottom end RB25 I would aim for around 13.2:1 at zero boost, 12.5:1 at around 6psi, 12:1 at 10psi going off to 11.8 high in the rev range.

completed the wideband tuning again. i had closed loop off and you could see the difference, even if you dialed in a lean INJ cell value after a few seconds closed loop would run and richen it back up to 14.7 which is kinda not helpful for light load / cruise areas. so ive tuned it with 02 feedback off and left it completely off as i've checked most of the load areas and im happy with the afr's coming out. i had to make a fair few adustments and i ended up loading the apexi rb25 default map for the first 8x8 cells and then leaning it out from there using datalogit, the hand controller was taking far too long. once i had adjusted the cells in 8x8 area the afrs were happy for light cruise on streets and also on the freeway

i must have done the previous tune with 02 feedback still on because as soon as 02 feedback was off the afrs coming out were too lean so my bad. but its off for good now and will see how it runs with it being off for a week.

ok so is what i have done an ok'ish principal ?

tuned it fairly lean on cruise / light load and as the load cells increased richen it up in steps and kept the rest of the cells how they were (max power tuned). this does mean some parts of the crusing along are at afr's of 16 or 15.5 in some parts, siuch as the first row of the rev points upto 2400rpm.

jack all load so why rich? then as we increase load up the afr and i aimed for 14.7 for 100km/h cruising. done all that with keep 02 feedback off completely

will run out this full tank with 02 feedback off and see how it goes

then will try it with 02 feedback back on. but 1 question i dont understand

whats the point of tuning say the first 8x8 cells and you dial in whatever AFR you feel is cool or right and then have 02 feedback turned on again when you are done and as soon as the throttle is steady closed loop comes along and dials the AFR back down to 14.7 so even if you decided AFR 15.5 is fine, as soon as you cruise for a few seconds it begins richening up to 14.7 again.

so is the ideal economy land

1) lean out the say 8x8 area with whatever AFR you feel is right / safe and have 02 feedback off

or

2) dial in 14.7afr in all of the 8x8 areas and have 02 feedback on and always run with 14.7 everywhere, at least in that 8x8 area regardless of rpm and/or load.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • No, I refuse to buy their cheap ass crap! I do need to order a bunch of different nuts/bolts to refill my nut/bolt wall though. Maybe you could go for a walk through Bunnings for me? (Or send me some stuff from your work? )   I really struggle to work out how the US standardised to Metric in what the 70s or 80s, and yet, half a century later, there's been little done to actually bring it into fruition. It truly baffles me    On the whole Fastenal thing, I went reading their site (My god they sell a lot of varied stuff!), and it seems like it really depends what store you're near if you can walk in and just grab a few small things, or if that branch is primarily distribution with only a small window of "counter time" available (if at all). That definitely makes it harder, as move locations and it drastically changes your ability for success   For things like your M6x1.0, if you want to work on your own Skyline, and you also have a "home workshop" I'd recommend setting yourself up a small Nut/Bolt wall/section. It doesn't even need to be big at all. Most things depending on the diameter, will be a specific pitch, like the M6x1, M5x0.7 etc. Bigger bolts is mostly 1.5, except for a small number of things and that will come down to torque. From memory bolts for the brake calipers (and other things that need a lot of torque) will end up being a 1.25mm pitch. Save up a few dollars, and order a range of nuts/bolts. If you want to minimise cost a little, buy something like M6 x 40, and M6x70mm (1mm pitch) in both. In addition, buy yourself an M6x1mm thread chaser. That way you have long bolts that you can cut down to size, and then chase the threads out. Funnily enough, I find what I'd pay here for ordering 5 bolts, I can pay about 50% more and you'll get 100 of them.   If that doesn't quite work out due to space / ability to buy plenty up front, then each time you need some bolts, order 100 of what ever you're getting. Put them in clearly marked containers. Over a few years, you'll acquire plenty of different sizes, and will end up ordering less and less. And the cost for 100 bolts won't be much more than you paid for your 5 you needed to order anyway  Just takes a little planning ahead, by investigating what nuts/bolts you'll need, and ordering them before doing the job.     Edit: If it's also primarily for working on just the Skyline, for some reason my brain is screaming that at some point, either Nissan, Nismo, (Or possibly a third party) was selling a "kit" of every nut and bolt in a Skyline, purely for people restoring/rebuilding. It'd likely be quite expensive, but would give you every/any nut/bolt you need for stock/factory things. I'm not sure if it's still available, or even if it actually fully came to market, it's just something niggling in the back of my brain that you could look into further if that sort of thing interested you? (It might have been for the R32 GTR or something specifically too, and not just any Skyline)
    • 90lb/min @ 20psi is wonderful, not so much of a problem with the G35-1050's compressor efficiency (aside from how bad they roll back at higher pressure ratios).  The issue is more to do with the turbine's flow, which is why I'm not sold on going an even higher flowing compressor with the same turbine.  I'd say go back over Motive DVD's testing of the G35 1050 and Hawkins's comments regarding exhaust back pressure issues with it, I'd need to go back but I have in my head he went to the biggest hotside and ended up sacrificing a lot of spool (so it ended up behaving like a bigger turbo) and still had EMAP issues.  I've heard various other experiences along the lines of that. At this stage at least I rate all I've seen about Xonas (for transparency I've not used one directly, but I have spoke plenty with people who have) to have low exhaust restriction for the response they offer for any given setup - basically they allow the engine to breathe, which is good for the engine and makes making power a lot easier.  You arguably don't have to even push quite the same amount of airflow through an engine to make the same power if you don't have the bum plugged up with exhaust gas struggling to escape the engine due to an underflowing turbine.   In terms of reliability, to be fair I've had great luck with Garrett turbos as well - my GT3076R lasted forever, then I sold it and the next owner had no issues, then that car got sold and it was still going strong last I ever heard about it.  The trick is with the old GT-series turbos the compressors etc were no way near as efficient as what we have these days, it was almost hard to push them into severe overspeed situations without having a boost leak or something - and that is what often starts the failure situation.    In terms of your G35 I'm pretty sure you're running yours within sensible limits, something people with Xonas and Precision turbos aren't often so inclined to do.  The "compressor maps" are "Joe blogs ran 45psi through his 6466 so I can do the same" and built their setup to send it to the moon.  I've seen EMAP and compressor speed data where people have actually set that stuff up on Precisions and Xonas which have been run hard and the comp speed numbers are very very exciting at times - like I've seen 76mm Precisions run at rpm that you ideally shouldn't run a G35 1050 lol.   I know people who have run G-series Garretts hard and hard a failure, then replaced them with Pulsar turbos as a cheap "get it going" stop gap with the intent of doing a proper upgrade when THAT fails... and are still running the same thing.   Like anything, ymmv and it's not always to do with the quality or trustworthiness of said product. I've been provided with a bunch of compressor maps for Turbosmart turbos and will update my list based off that, they could prove to interesting reading and an interesting alternative as well.
    • Just cage it, call it a race car, and then fall in love with the chirp chirps through pit area!   Also, this is coming from someone with a completely locked diff...
    • I still have an old R32R left over from when they were a thing in the early 2000's. It was, for its time, done about right. But its time was 20 years ago.  I did try and update it a while back but it was cruelled by a (recommended) muppet of a tuna who couldnt tell his MAP from his TPS. The original spec was: Power FC, 700cc Sards, Nismo pump, 2860-5's, cams (Basically Poncam A's), Z32 AFM's and a half sorted oiling system. Thereabouts 430rwhp irrespective of what was done. So, yeah, very 1990's. I eventually got sick of it not being very refined and bought a Link G4 PNP with some 1000cc Bosch injectors. This was tuned badly and I put the car in the shed for a few years whilst I sulked and went and did other things. Ive come around to the idea of getting it going again so it has a new gearbox installed and some other minor things in the planning. So my questions are, variously (In the context of keeping the Link) What other sensors should I be running eg It has no wideband on it at the moment, nor fuel pressure. $? Is it worth chucking the old ignition system (ignitors etc) for new ignition coils? $2k? Cam/crank angle sensors? Can keep the aircon? $? Anything else? Sorry to launch another what should I do with my car thread but, you know, what should I do with my car? Random photo for historical context.
    • If you think that's harsh, go experience a KAAZ 🥲 Thoughts and prayers for Dose. I had mine modified by a diff shop to make it less brutal, no idea what they did but it's not as brutal as before. The Asian in me was being tight before and went KAAZ instead of a Nismo, lesson learned.
×
×
  • Create New...